Strange Flashes | Science Alert

 "We've never seen this dramatic variability in the rate at which it's flashing," Masterson says. "This looked absolutely nothing like a normal black hole."
So what in the Universe could be going on? To figure that out, the researchers needed to examine the clues: the wavelength of light and the periodicity of the flickering.

Strange Flashes Could Be Signs of Closest Object Seen Near a Black Hole

Space14 January 2025

ByMichelle Starr

An artist's impression of the extreme gravitational environment around the supermassive black hole of 1ES 1927+654 (Aurore Simonnet/Sonoma State University)

Some 275 million light-years from the Milky Way lies a true cosmic mystery.
There, in the heart of a galaxy named 1ES 1927+654, squats a supermassive black hole whose monkeyshines and hijinks have baffled astronomers for years.
Now, we might finally have an explanation for at least some of its wild misbehavior: an orbiting white dwarf star veering precariously close to the brink of the black hole's event horizon, the point beyond which no matter can ever return.

"This would be the closest thing that we know of around any black hole," says physicist Megan Masterson of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. "This tells us that objects like white dwarfs may be able to live very close to an event horizon for a relatively extended period of time."

Black holes themselves emit no light, but the supermassive black holes at the centers of galaxies are often surrounded by huge clouds of material. It's this material, heated by friction and gravity as it swirls in orbit around the black hole, that blazes with light.

When this light changes, astronomers can study it to figure out what events might be taking place in the black hole's vicinity. For example, we know what it looks like when a passing star gets caught in a black hole's gravitational field and torn asunder to be devoured over time.

An artist's impression of the disappearing corona. (NASA/JPL-Caltech)

A relatively modest beast clocking in at around 1 million times the mass of the Sun, the black hole at the center of 1ES 1927+654 looked relatively normal until 2018, when its surrounding corona winked out of visibility before gradually brightening to nearly 20 times its previous luminosity.

• This was puzzling. One analysis suggested that it might be the result of a black hole polar reversal. Having never never seen anything like it before, scientists kept an eye on 1ES 1927+654 to see if anything else of note occurred.
  

In June 2022, something did.
X-ray data recorded by the European Space Agency's XMM-Newton space telescope showed that the galactic nucleus had started fluctuating in brightness. The X-ray output of the black hole was varying by about 10 percent, on timescales of around 18 minutes.
This is not unheard-of black hole behavior. Such fluctuations are known as quasi-periodic oscillations, and their exact cause or causes are unknown. But 1ES 1927+654 just had to make it even weirder. Over the course of two years, the time between the fluctuations narrowed from around 18 minutes to under seven.

An artist's impression of a white dwarf kicking up flares of light as it surfs the event horizon of the supermassive black hole. (Aurore Simonnet/Sonoma State University)

. . ."Seeing something in the X-rays is already telling you you're pretty close to the black hole," says physicist Erin Kara of MIT. "When you see variability on the timescale of minutes, that's close to the event horizon, and the first thing your mind goes to is circular motion, and whether something could be orbiting around the black hole."

The researchers ran through the available scenarios and determined that the most likely option is a dense object in the material orbiting the black hole, gradually getting closer. As its orbit shrinks, the time between flashes of light as circles the black hole shortens. 

• That means this object is whipping around an event horizon with a radius 4.2 times that of our Sun's in just seven minutes.
  

The team's calculations show that this object is probably a white dwarf star; that is, the collapsed core of a low-mass star that has ejected its outer material as it died. The mass for this object is around 0.1 times the mass of the Sun, packed into a sphere between the Earth and the Moon in diameter.

If this is the case, the white dwarf may yet survive the encounter. At such close proximity, the black hole is probably tearing off the white dwarf's outer material, which gives the tortured star enough kickback momentum to keep it from passing the point of no return. White dwarfs are also really dense, which would be keeping it from coming apart like a normal star would.
This could mean that it will eventually retreat away from the black hole to a safer distance. If the team's analysis is correct, they will be able to observe this retreat in a lengthening period in the X-ray oscillations. 

Whatever happens, though, this black hole is far from done teaching us about the most extreme gravitational environments in the Universe.
"The one thing I've learned with this source is to never stop looking at it because it will probably teach us something new," Masterson says. "The next step is just to keep our eyes open."
The research has been presented at the 245th meeting of the American Astronomical Society. It has also been accepted in Nature, and is available on preprint server arXiv.