The Judges Standing Up to Trump

The Trump Administration has been treating court orders like mere suggestions. Ruth Marcus on the judges who are fighting back.

Thursday, April 17, 2025

Also in this newsletter: • People either love or hate Phish • An M.I.T. professor on how China is likely to respond to U.S. tariffs • Richard Brody reviews Ryan Coogler’s new film, “Sinners” Photograph by Jose Luis Magana / AP Ruth Marcus Marcus writes about politics and the law. We’re past the point of wondering whether the Trump Administration will violate court orders. It will—even as it refuses to acknowledge the obvious defiance. The pressing question is how forcefully judges will respond—and whether the Supreme Court will back them up. Developments this week bode well, at least when it comes to the first part of that challenge. On Tuesday, the U.S. district judge Paula Xinis, of Maryland, hearing the case of Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia—the Salvadoran man illegally deported to and imprisoned in El Salvador—raised the prospect of contempt proceedings against the government. For good reason: the Trump Administration’s refusal to provide any information about what it is—or, more to the point, isn’t—doing to obtain Abrego Garcia’s release doesn’t just violate Xinis’s previous instructions; it flies in the face of the Supreme Court’s ruling that the Administration must “ ‘facilitate’ Abrego Garcia’s release from custody” and “share what it can” about its efforts to do so. Xinis, upping the ante in the face of the government’s non-answers, told White House attorneys to expect “two weeks of intense discovery.” She set a schedule for Abrego Garcia’s lawyers to seek government documents and to question Administration officials, adding pointedly, “Should Defendants fail or refuse to engage in the above-described discovery in good faith, Plaintiffs are free to seek separate sanctions on an expedited basis.” This judge is not backing down—nor should she. Gratifyingly, she was backed up by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, which issued a swift and stark rebuke of the Administration on Thursday, in turning down its request to block Xinis’s order. The Administration’s position “should be shocking not only to judges, but to the intuitive sense of liberty that Americans far removed from courthouses still hold dear,” Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson III, a Ronald Reagan appointee, wrote. The U.S. district judge James Boasberg, in the District of Columbia, is several weeks further along in dealing with the Administration’s obstructionism. He is not backing down, either. On Wednesday, Boasberg issued a scorcher of a ruling: forty-six pages detailing the government’s frenzied efforts to ship hundreds of Venezuelan men to El Salvador without due process, and its blatant violation of Boasberg’s efforts to prevent those deportations. The underlying case is out of Boasberg’s hands, as the Supreme Court said it had been brought in the wrong jurisdiction. But the judge insists that the Court’s dismissal isn’t the end of the matter, for a simple reason: “The Constitution does not tolerate willful disobedience of judicial orders—especially by officials of a coordinate branch who have sworn an oath to uphold it.” The government’s actions, Boasberg found, “demonstrate a willful disregard” for his order, enough to “conclude that probable cause exists to find the Government in criminal contempt.” What next? The government could fix the problem by obtaining custody of the Venezuelans and giving them a hearing, Boasberg said, or it could propose some other remedy, which he would consider. Failing that, he would move on to figuring out who exactly to charge with contempt. And, if the Trump Administration declined to prosecute that person (which it will almost certainly do), Boasberg added, he would appoint an outside lawyer to do the job, a move that is mandated under the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure but not often used. (If deployed, brace for litigation over whether that violates the Constitution’s separation of powers.) Boasberg is playing judicial hardball, but it is well warranted. The Administration has acted as though orders from lower courts can be sneered at. The Supreme Court has effectively encouraged this behavior. In the Abrego Garcia case, the Court’s mixed-message ruling (distinguishing between “facilitating” and “effectuating” Abrego Garcia’s return and noting the “due regard for the deference owed to the Executive Branch in the conduct of foreign affairs”) gave the Administration an opening to balk. In the Venezuelan case, as the three dissenting liberal Justices noted, the government’s conduct posed “an extraordinary threat to the rule of law,” and yet the majority “now rewards the Government for its behavior” by stepping in with emergency intervention. The stakes here for the rule of law couldn’t be higher, but the right approach for courts should be familiar to anyone who has raised a toddler. Every parent eventually learns the importance of clear rules and logical consequences. In dealing with this Administration, the Justices should, too. For more: Ruth Marcus speaks with David Remnick on The New Yorker Radio Hour about whether the Supreme Court will yield to Donald Trump. The New Yorker upholds the highest standards of reporting, research, and fact checking. Support our journalism by subscribing » Editor’s Pick Profiles After Forty Years, Phish Isn’t Seeking Resolution People who love Phish do so with a quasi-religious devotion. People who dislike Phish do so with an equal fervor. By Amanda Petrusich More from The New Yorker Q. & A. China’s Plan to Fight Trump’s Trade War A professor at M.I.T. on how Xi Jinping is likely to respond to U.S. tariffs and why the standoff won’t weaken the Chinese Communist Party’s grip on power. By Isaac Chotiner The Current Cinema “Sinners” Is a Virtuosic Fusion of Historical Realism and Horror Ryan Coogler’s vampire movie mines vampirism’s symbolic potential to tell a tale of exploitation and Black music in nineteen-thirties Mississippi. By Richard Brody The Theatre London Theatre Shimmers with Mirrors and Memory New productions of Shakespeare’s “Richard II,” Annie Ernaux’s “The Years,” Robert Icke’s “Manhunt,” Tennessee Williams’s “The Glass Menagerie,” and more. By Helen Shaw Critics at Large: The new movie “Warfare” reconstructs an ill-fated 2006 mission in Iraq from the memories of the Navy SEALs involved. Does this method bring us closer to the reality of combat? Listen and follow » Daily Cartoon

Cartoon by Ivan Ehlers

“Just wait till 2028 and things will go right back to how they were.”

See mor

*** 87 DAYS*** >> JUST IN: Sec. Marco Rubio Says US Willing To Walk Away From Peace Talks ...

Superman | Superman Day - Behind The Scenes Look

 

Apr 18, 2025 #Superman #LookUp #SupermanDay

We’re just getting started. 

 #Superman - Only in Theaters and @imax, July 11 #LookUp #SupermanDay 

 “Superman,” DC Studios’ first feature film to hit the big screen, is set to soar into theaters worldwide this summer from Warner Bros. Pictures. 

• In his signature style, James Gunn takes on the original superhero in the newly imagined DC universe with a singular blend of epic action, humor and heart, delivering a Superman who’s driven by compassion and an inherent belief in the goodness of humankind. 

 DC Studios heads Peter Safran and Gunn are producing the film, which Gunn directs from his own screenplay, based on characters from DC, Superman created by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster. 

The film stars 

• David Corenswet (“Twisters,” “Hollywood”) in the dual role of Superman/Clark Kent, 
• Rachel Brosnahan (“The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel”) as Lois Lane and 
• Nicholas Hoult (the “X-Men” movies, “Juror #2”) as Lex Luthor. 

 

The film also stars 

1. Edi Gathegi (“For All Mankind”), 
2. Anthony Carrigan (“Barry,” “Gotham”), 
3. Nathan Fillion (the “Guardians of the Galaxy” films, “The Suicide Squad”), 
4. Isabela Merced (“Alien Romulus”), 
5. Skyler Gisondo (“Licorice Pizza,” “Booksmart”), 
6. Sara Sampaio (“At Midnight”), 
7. María Gabriela de Faría (“The Moodys”), 
8. Wendell Pierce (“Selma,” “Tom Clancy’s Jack Ryan”), 
9. Alan Tudyk (“Andor”), 
10. Pruitt Taylor Vince (“Bird Box”) and 
11. Neva Howell (“Greedy People”). 

 

 “Superman” is executive produced by Nikolas Korda, Chantal Nong Vo and Lars Winther. 

 

Behind the camera, Gunn is joined by frequent collaborators, including 

• director of photography Henry Braham, 
• production designer Beth Mickle, 
• costume designer Judianna Makovsky and 
• composer John Murphy, along with composer David Fleming (“The Last of Us”), 
• editors William Hoy (“The Batman”), Jason Ballantine (the “IT” films, “The Flash”) and Craig Alpert (“Deadpool 2,” “Blue Beetle”). 

 

DC Studios Presents a Troll Court Entertainment/The Safran Company Production, A James Gunn Film, “Superman,” which will be in theaters and IMAX® nationwide on July 11, 2025, and internationally beginning 9 July 2025, distributed by Warner Bros. Pictures.

Today's Aerospace & Defense Headlines

  

US Army Awards BAE $162M (GBP124M) Contract for New M777 Structures

Apr 15, 2025

Defense Land Systems Weapons

Archer Unveils Vision For New York Air Taxi Network, Including Routes Between Manhattan and Nearby Airports in Partnership with United Airlines

Apr 17, 2025

Aerospace Aviation Commercial Aircraft

BAE Continues Building Critical Structures for Columbia-class Submarine

Apr 17, 2025

Defense Naval Systems North America

NGC's Minotaur IV Rocket Successfully Launches National Security Payload for NRO

Northrop Grumman Corporation (NYSE: NOC) successfully launched the NROL-174 mission on a Minotaur IV rocket for the National Reconnaissance Office from Space...

Apr 17, 2025

Aerospace Space

Aircraft Lighting Market - Global Forecast to 2029

by Technology (LED, HID, Halogen, NVIS), Light Type (Interior (Signage, Reading, Ceiling & Wall lights), Exterior (Emergency, Anti-collision, Search Lights), Cockpit), End User, Aircraft Type, Region

Shield AI Surpasses 130 V-BAT Sorties in Ukraine in Partnership With Ukrainian Forces

Shield AI, the deep-tech company building state-of-the-art autonomy software products and defense aircraft, announced today that its Kyiv-based operations team...

Apr 17, 2025

Defense Military UAS Military Unmanned Systems Unmanned Systems

Retia and Axon Vision Enter Strategic Partnership in the Field of Electronic Systems for Military Armored Vehicles

Retia has entered a strategic partnership with the Israeli company Axon Vision, which represents the first step in a broader cooperation aimed not only at...

Apr 17, 2025

Defense Protection Vehicles Europe

DoD Energy & Power Summit 2025

Washington, DC
Jul 9 - 10, 2025

Azorra Delivers Mongolia's 1st Embraer E195-E2 to Hunnu Air

Azorra has delivered the first of two new Embraer E195-E2 aircraft to Hunnu Air, marking a new partnership for the lessor and the first E2 to operate in...

Apr 17, 2025

Aerospace Aviation Commercial Aircraft

MGCS Project Company Gmbh (MPC) Established in Cologne

Apr 18, 2025

Blighter Makes Debut at IQDEX in Iraq To Showcase Smart Border Surveillance Radars

Apr 17, 2025

Kratos Receives Approximate $30M Sole Source Air Defense System Hardware Production Award

Apr 17, 2025

Webb Spots Clues of Black Hole at Heart of Nearby Galaxy M83

Apr 17, 2025

NASA Studies Wind Effects and Aircraft Tracking with Joby Aircraft

Apr 17, 2025

GA-ASI Announces Technology Investments From Blue Magic Netherlands

Apr 16, 2025

Gulfstream G800 Earns FAA and EASA Certifications

Apr 16, 2025

U.S. Navy, ROK Navy Complete Combined Mine Warfare Exercise

Apr 16, 2025

Hanwha and WB Group Sign Term Sheet Agreement for Guided Missile JV in Poland

Apr 15, 2025

Fincantieri and Thyssenkrupp Marine Systems Partner for Philippines Submarines Project

Apr 16, 2025

L3Harris Expands Indiana Facility to Support America's Golden Dome

Apr 15, 2025

Thales Delivers Complete Set of Dual TWTs for the Optus-11 Satellite, Developed by Airbus Defence and Space

Apr 17, 2025

British Soldiers Take Down Drone Swarm in Groundbreaking Use of Radio Wave Weapon

Apr 17, 2025

"Big Surprise": Astronomers Find Planet in Perpendicular Orbit Around Pair of Stars

Apr 16, 2025

Volvo Defense at DEFEA 2025: Highly capable solutions for the toughest conditions

Apr 16, 2025

Trump administration is destroying the US tourism industry | Grumpy Canadian from Grumpy’s Russo-Ukraine War Brief

 

Watch now

Trump administration is destroying the US tourism industry

Grumpy Canadian Apr 18

READ IN APP

US tourism will be devastated and the Trump administration is unapologetic

Grumpy’s Russo-Ukraine War Brief is free today. But if you enjoyed this post, you can tell Grumpy’s Russo-Ukraine War Brief that their writing is valuable by pledging a future subscription. You won't be charged unless they enable payments.

Cartoon Carousel The nation’s cartoonists on the week in politics | By POLITICO STAFF 04/18/2025 05:00 AM EDT

Every week political cartoonists throughout the country and across the political spectrum apply their ink-stained skills to capture the foibles, memes, hypocrisies and other head-slapping events in the world of politics. 

The fruits of these labors are hundreds of cartoons that entertain and enrage readers of all political stripes. 

Here's an offering of the best of this week's crop, picked fresh off the Toonosphere. 

Edited by Matt Wuerker.

CARTOON CAROUSEL

The nation’s cartoonists on the week in politics

By POLITICO Staff