30 March 2018

ICYMI: There's a CLOUD ACT in the Omnibus Spending Bill

Posted on February 8, 2018 by  
Source: http://www.rstreet.org/2018/02/08        

CLOUD Act highlights need to modernize cross-border data framework
cloud-data
*This post was co-authored by Charles Duan, Associate Director of Technology and Innovation Policy at R Street.
Blogger Note: Except for the image above, the other three images have been inserted from different sources
On Wednesday, Sens. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah; Christopher Coons, D-Del.; Lindsey Graham, R-S.C.; and Sheldon Whitehouse, D-R.I., introduced the Clarifying Lawful Overseas Use of Data (CLOUD) Act, which deals with law enforcement’s access to communications information stored in the cloud.
"We think the CLOUD Act is an important first step to dealing with the difficult problem of cloud data stored overseas and encourage policymakers to use the bill as a key component in reforming the legal procedures for law-enforcement access to online communications..."
This bill arises in the context of United States v. Microsoft, currently pending at the Supreme Court. That case will consider whether U.S. law enforcement can legally obtain emails stored on Microsoft’s cloud email service when those emails are physically stored on servers in a foreign country. The underlying issues are complex yet important to every American who uses cloud services. R Street filed an amicus brief with the Supreme Court to emphasize these complexities.
The depth and difficulty of the issue also highlights the need for a legislative solution. Indeed, as global demands for cross-border data increase, frustrations with the status quo will continue to worsen.
Blogger Note: Please watch and hear the comments by Amitai Etzioni in another post featured on this blog about other extra-territorial remedies in the form of bilateral or multilateral treaties that other countries may wish to enter into . . . .    
If left unaddressed, these frustrations will push nations toward undesirable policy alternatives, including data-localization and stricter controls on the internet. Allowing the Supreme Court to be the final arbiter on cloud data-access would force a choice between two extremes, neither of which is desirable.
It is incumbent on Congress to think prospectively and craft a path forward that accounts for the myriad technological and international legal ramifications of cloud data storage.
If enacted, the CLOUD Act would establish a framework for U.S. law enforcement to obtain emails stored on foreign cloud servers, as in the Microsoft case. The government is expected to withdraw the case if the bill is enacted. The framework largely mirrors the International Communications Privacy Act (ICPA), which R Street previously supported.
At the same time, the larger framework for law enforcement’s access to electronic communications is decades old and widely considered outdated. The CLOUD Act currently is limited to the extraterritoriality issues discussed above, and it neglects to address whether warrants or other showings of cause ought to be required as part of the procedure for accessing cloud-stored data.
R Street has been supportive of reforming the Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA) – the law governing this larger communications framework – to extend the warrant requirement to all content data, not just those less than 180 days old.
There is widespread support for such reform, with the Email Privacy Act having passed the House last year by voice vote. The right way forward, in our view, is to use the CLOUD Act not as a complete solution, but rather as a component of these broader efforts to bring electronic communications law into the 21st century.
 

Public Participation? What's It Take Here In Mesa???

Yes, the Federal Aviation Authority FAA, the Environmental Protection Agency EPA, and as far as we know so did the City of Mesa and so did the Phoenix Mesa  Gateway Airport  Authority PMGAA follow the rules for the proposed Northeast Area Development Plan and Associated Improvements Project at Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport, Mesa, Maricopa County, Arizona.
First of all, it's interesting to note that the January 2017 assessment had a very extended public outreach and required notice to the public to submit comments. Among other ways to publish the notice for public participation it was circulated in two area publications, one of which was The Arizona Business Gazette.
How many comments were received? 2
Those 2 [two] were not from members of public but from industries.
If you look at Section 1.3 Existing Deficiencies it says this:
The existing terminal complex - in its current configuration - is a disparate, inefficient collection of terminal buildings. The 25-acre footprint has extremely limited space for any revenue-producing development (See Section 1.4 also)
_________________________________________________


Public review & comments sought on Draft Environmental Assessment for proposed Falcon Tech Center project
October 12, 2017 at 8:00 pm
Notice is hereby given that the City of Mesa, Arizona is seeking Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) approval of an Airport Layout Plan change for Mesa-Falcon Field Airport for the proposed Falcon Tech Center project. The planned development would...
_________________________________________________________________________________
There's this announcement from Gateway Airport
http://www.gatewayairport.com/EnvironmentalAssessment.aspx that provides a link to the 1,078-page FONSI
Environmental Assessment for Northeast Area Development Plan                                                               The Federal Aviation Administration has announced that a “Finding of No Significant Impact” (FONSI) and Record of Decision (ROD) has been approved based upon results of a Final Environmental Assessment for the proposed Northeast Area Development Plan and Associated Improvements Project at Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport, Mesa, Maricopa County, Arizona.        
The FONSI/ROD indicates that the proposed action is consistent with existing environmental policies and objectives as set forth in the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 in that it will not significantly affect the quality of the human environment. 
Project Map        
_________________________________________________________________________
. . . and there's also this media release from The City of Mesa Newsroom 
(with a conceptual rendering of Falcon Tech Center)
http://mesanow.org/news/public/article/2066
MEDIA RELEASE
Notice of Finding of No Significant Impact and availability of Final Environmental Assessment for the proposed Falcon Tech Center at Mesa-Falcon Field, Mesa, AZ
March 23, 2018 at 10:30 pm
The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has announced that a Finding of No Significant Impact (FONSI) has been approved based on the results of a February 2018 Final Environmental Assessment (EA) for an Airport Layout Plan change for the Mesa-Falcon Field Airport for the proposed Falcon Tech Center project.
The planned development will cater to the medical and technology industries, offering long-term leases (up to 40 years), and be located on approximately 70 acres west of North Greenfield Road. Anticipated primary uses include light manufacturing and research and development and associated laboratories, as well as office and administrative facilities.
The FONSI indicates that the Proposed Action is consistent with existing environmental policies and objectives as set forth in the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 in that it will not significantly affect the quality of the human environment. The Final EA and FONSI are available for review at:
http://www.falconfieldairport.com/about-us/documents-forms, www.MesaFalconDistrict.com, www.mesamedicaldevice.com, and at the following physical locations during normal business hours:

o Falcon Field Airport Administration Office, 4800 E. Falcon Drive, Mesa, AZ 85215
o City of Mesa Engineering Department, 20 E. Main Street, #500, Mesa, AZ 85201
o Mesa Main Library, 64 E. 1st Street, Mesa, AZ 85201
o FAA Phoenix Airports District Office, 3800 N. Central Avenue, #1025, Phoenix, AZ 8501


_______________________________________________________________________
Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport to Facilitate Crossborder Commerce
First International Air Cargo Hub to House Both Mexican and US Customs
March 25th, 2018 | Written by
 

 

 

Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport Terminal Expansion Phase 2:
Project Value:$10,562,163

  • Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport Terminal Expansion Phase 2
  • Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport Terminal Expansion Phase 2
  • Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport Terminal Expansion Phase 2
  • Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport Terminal Expansion Phase 2
 
________________________________________________________________________
RELATED CONTENT:
 

Jesus Christ! He's A Superstar! ROCK OPERA So more exciting than "A Pageant"


Published on Sep 14, 2006
Views: 8,427,183 
"Jesus Christ Superstar is a 1970 rock opera with music by Andrew Lloyd Webber and lyrics by Tim Rice. The musical started as a rock opera concept album before its Broadway debut in 1971."
 
Carl Anderson performing "Superstar" on the movie Jesus Christ Superstar made in the 70´s. I can tell for sure this is the BEST performance i´ve ever seen of JCS ever. Carl Anderson (Judas) and Ted Neeley (Jesus Christ) are just GREAT.

Polar Bears and Nuclear Submarines | Mini Ice Age 2015-2035 (564)


Published on Mar 28, 2018
Views: 8,286
The British Navy takes part in ICEX exercises that take place every two years and last for several weeks. Royal Navy submarine HMS Trenchant broke through the Arctic ice about seven days ago to join two US submarines for the exercise.

At the same time, US submarines Hartford and Connecticut were stuck in the Arctic ice as they were training an attack on Russia. According to the legend of the exercises, the US submarines were supposed to surface and strike conditional targets in Russia, but the thick ice prevented them from fulfilling the scenario of the exercise.

Strangely as they subs surfaced, three well fed polar bears approached the vessels. In the middle of the Arctic what are the chances of 3x polar bears coming, all well fed, girth and on the prowl, plus sea ice too thick to surface all in the warmest least sea ice ever.

These sea ice accounts are from the British and US Navies.
https://www.veteranstoday.com/2018/03...

ADAPT 2030 on PayPal paypal.me/adapt2030

ADAPT 2030 Mini Ice Age FB Page
https://www.facebook.com/Miniiceage
Content Provided by David DuByne http://www.oilseedcrops.org
You can also find this Mini Ice Age Conversations podcast on iTunes / Stitcher Radio / Soundcloud

True Leaf Organic Seeds ADAPT 2030 Link
http://www.pjtra.com/t/SkNITkxPS0xDR0...

YES THEY ARE: The Times They Are A Changing

Peter, Paul  & Mary ... Lend a hand

Exactly What We Didn't Want To See > Solar Flares Erupting + MORE!!

M6.9 Quake
Published on Mar 30, 2018
Views: 13,477
Daily Sun, Earth and Space Science
Energy from Space | The Shift Has Begun:
https://youtu.be/nsqZJP54shg

What Happens to Your Body While You Are Having Sex?

Got the urge?
Published on Mar 29, 2018
Views: 279,953
Do you cuddle up, have a chat, talk about deep things, or even request a favor of your lover? According to research, these are all common, but what happens to our bodies during and after sex? That’s what we’ll find out today, in this episode of the Infographics Show, What Happens to Your Body While You Are Having Sex?

SUBSCRIBE TO US -►
http://bit.ly/TheInfographicsShow

BushMaster Production Increase Expands Orbital ATK

The Insider
Orbital ATK to expand operations in Mesa, AZ
March 29, 2018 | John Lang
Orbital ATK announced plans today to expand the company's production facility in Mesa, AZ.
The new 36,000-square-foot facility will support the company's ability to increase production capacity through collocating Orbital ATK's warehouse and manufacturing operations into one site.

Its current site builds the Bushmaster family of medium-caliber cannons that are supplied to the U.S. military and more than 50 other countries.
Image result for bushmaster orbital atk
When complete, the capital investment will nearly double Orbital ATK's current production capacity and help address future growth requirements as U.S. and allied militaries are increasing their current defense capabilities in response to worldwide threats, according to a company statement.
The expanded facility is scheduled to become fully operational before the end of the year, the statement reads. The factory currently employs nearly 200 full-time workers and the company plans to add an additional 50 to 60 new engineering, program management and manufacturing technicians as a result of the increased campus footprint.
"This will include the fully modernized and secure production facility and separate operations headquarters where engineering, program management, business development and various operations support activities occur," Orbital said.

Source > https://insidedefense.com 
_________________________________________________________________________
 

 

JEDI Cloud > $10B 10-Year IDIQ Department of Defense Contract

Hmmm... if you would to re-invent or re-imagine your life where would U go?? Go for IT!
IT=Internet Tech and everything - the IoT or Internet of Everything -  is going 'into the Cloud'
The Insider
DOD plans to release second draft solicitation for JEDI cloud
March 26, 2018 | Justin Doubleday 
The Defense Department plans to release a second draft request for proposals for the Joint Enterprise Defense Infrastructure (JEDI) cloud competition in April after the first draft received more than 1,000 comments.
The single-award strategy has proven controversial, with many companies and industry associations arguing DOD should use multiple awards for services that are expected to be used throughout the department.
In a March 24 update to the Federal Business Opportunities website, the JEDI cloud team announced it had received 1,089 comments from 46 vendors, two associations and three government agencies on the first draft RFP released March 7.
"We appreciate industry's participation in the draft solicitation process and are confident that these inputs will help us to refine and clarify the requirement," the posting states. "DOD remains committed to a transparent process. To that end, the JEDI Cloud team intends to release answers to all previously submitted comments/questions along with a second draft solicitation package for additional comment during the week of April 9."
DOD still plans to release the final RFP in early May, the notice adds.
The Pentagon is planning the JEDI contract as a single, indefinite-delivery, indefinite-quantity award to provide cloud services DOD-wide, officials told companies during a March 7 industry day held to unveil the first draft RFP.
The contract will include options to extend it upwards of 10 years, and DOD Chief Management Officer Jay Gibson told reporters it's fair to characterize it as a "multibillion-dollar" award.
The issue has also garnered congressional attention, as lawmakers want DOD to provide them with more details on the acquisition strategy.
 
_________________________________________________________________________
According to this report  published 09 March 2018 | 3:04 pm on MeriTalk Improving the Outcomes of Government IT
"The Department of Defense (DoD) on Wednesday sketched out plans for a swift, multibillion dollar move to a comprehensive cloud infrastructure, while leaving a lot of the details to be filled in along the way. . .  
DoD wants to make core services–covering the spectrum of computing, storage, and networking, including advanced analytics and data management–available via the cloud to the military services and defense components all the way out to deployed forces in austere environments. During the industry day event, officials described the push to the cloud as a transformational step in aligning the department’s operations with the technology landscape and demands of the 21st century.
And DoD expects a fast-moving procurement. It released a draft solicitation to coincide with the industry day, with a two-week window for initial responses (due March 21), a final solicitation scheduled in May, and the IDIQ award in to be made in September.
DoD plans to have JEDI services online in fiscal 2019, with more advanced capabilities added in 2020.
The department hasn’t officially put a price on the contract, which analysts speculate could be as much as $10 billion, but DoD Chief Management Officer Jay Gibson, in a call with reporters after the event, did allow that, “It’s fair to say we anticipate that this will be a multibillion dollar procurement.”
One rumbling in the contractor community is that the JEDI solicitation is inclined toward favoring Amazon Web Services (AWS), the biggest player in cloud services.
AWS has a 10-year contract with the CIA for services to the Intelligence Community, is already authorized at Impact Level 5, and recently launched as Secret-level region open to government customers outside of the IC.
AWS is considered one of the favorites for the JEDI contract.
In a tangential development, after DoD recently awarded a fast-track $950 million contract to REAN Cloud, Oracle filed a protest casting aspersions on the secretive process behind the award and REAN’s ties to AWS. DoD this week did a quick about-face, cutting the value of that deal to $65 million and limiting its scope to the U.S. Transportation Command. . . "
 
_________________________________________________________________________
 
Related Content:
 
DOD to clarify its cloud plans with industry day
By Lauren C. Williams Feb 15, 2018
Protest on JEDI Cloud Support Contract Dismissed
By Frank Konkel
The Government Accountability Office dismissed a bid protest filed in February against a $7 million sole-source cloud support contract related to the Defense Department’s JEDI Acquisition.
A bid protest filed against a $7 million cloud support contract for the Defense Department’s effort to move to an enterprisewide commercial cloud has been dismissed.
The $7 million cloud support contract attracted attention in February when the department selected a little-known contractor, Eagle Harbor Solutions LLC, for such a high-profile award. The contract is to provide consulting support services to the Cloud Executive Steering Committee, which is playing a major role in the Pentagon’s Joint Enterprise Defense Infrastructure cloud acquisition.
A Nextgov investigation found the company, an Alaska Native-owned 8(a) small disadvantaged business, had only a single employee and little past performance in government according to government procurement records. The company later sent a statement to Nextgov stating it had a staff of five, and that its corporate structure allowed it to share certain staff with sister companies of its parent company, Koniag Inc.
The protest, lodged by Interoperability Clearinghouse on Feb. 5, alleged the Defense Department failed to conduct a reasonable responsibility determination of Eagle Harbor Solutions’ capabilities and resources in awarding it a sole-source contract to support the JEDI cloud acquisition.
The Government Accountability Office dismissed by the protest on March 12, deciding that Interoperability Clearinghouse, a not-for-profit entity based in Alexandria, Virginia, “is not an interested party to challenge this sole-source award to an Alaska Native Corporation under the Small Business Administration’s 8(a) program.”
While agencies do sometimes cease work on a contract during a bid protest, there is no indication the Defense Department slowed its work during the duration of the protest. Defense officials held an industry day event and released a draft request for proposals last week for its JEDI cloud acquisition, would experts estimate could be worth as much as $10 billion over 10 years.
The Defense Department did not respond to an immediate request for comment
Source: http://www.nextgov.com
 
 
 
 
Mar 7, 2018 - The Defense Department shed some light on its much-anticipated Joint Enterprise Defense Infrastructure (JEDI) cloud acquisition at a March 7 industry day, and outlined a surprisingly short timeframe for finalizing a multi-billion, single-award contract. DOD officials hope to have a final request for proposals ...
 
 
Mar 9, 2018 - On March 7th, the Department of Defense (DoD) held its Joint Enterprise Defense Initiative (JEDI) Cloud Industry Day and released its draft JEDI Cloud Request for Proposals (the RFP). DoD announced, and the draft RFP reflects, a single-award IDIQ approach to execute a contract lasting up to 10-years for ...
 
Mar 14, 2018 - What does a winning proposal look like for the 10-year, single-award, $10 billion Joint Enterprise Defense Infrastructure (JEDI) commercial cloud contract? That will probably depend on contractor responses to the technical attributes featured in JEDI's draft RFP, such as evaluation, price, and other critical ...
 
Mar 7, 2018 - Defense Digital Service Director Chris Lynch speak during the JEDI Cloud Industry Day in Arlington, Va. March 7, 2018. The unclassified event outlined the Defense Dept.'s acquisition plans for the Joint Enterprise Defense Infrastructure (JEDI) Cloud. (DoD photo by EJ Hersom) ...
 

29 March 2018

US-MADE MISSILE DEFENSES SPECTACULARLY FAILED IN SAUDI ARABIA || WARTHOG...


Published on Mar 29, 2018
Views: 1,275
At least five American-made Patriot missiles apparently missed, malfunctioned, or otherwise failed when Saudi forces tried to intercept a barrage of rockets targeting Riyadh on March 25.
By: David Axe

How fashion helps us express who we are -- and what we stand for | Kaust...


Published on Mar 28, 2018
Views: 21,000+
No one thinks twice about a woman wearing blue jeans in New York City -- but when Nobel laureate Malala wears them, it's a political act. Around the globe, individuality can be a crime, and clothing can be a form of protest. In a talk about the power of what we wear, Kaustav Dey examines how fashion gives us a nonverbal language of dissent and encourages us to embrace our authentic selves.

Mesa Morning Live: Mesa Industry and Defense Council

Keeping U informed
Published on Mar 28, 2018
Views: 3
To learn more contact Sally Harrison at the Mesa Chamber of Commerce: http://www.mesachamber.org/

Solar Wind, Electric Flares, Darkness Galaxy | S0 News Mar.29.2018


Published on Mar 29, 2018
Views: 2,835
Daily Sun, Earth and Space Science
Energy from Space | The Shift Has Begun: https://youtu.be/nsqZJP54shg

Amitai Etzioni > Modern Surveillance & Privacy

This post today is about current topics for discussion and goodnteachers growing out of the chance one recent evening to hear someone who was a guest lecturer in a Social Psychology class while your MesaZona blogger was a student in the College of Arts & Sciences at Georgetown University: Amitai Etzioni
That was 50 years ago, probably before many readers of this site were born. Fast-forward to now to see that the distinguished author and Professor of International Relations at George Washington University is moderating a forum of Civil Dialogues in Washington DC.
The first one tackles critical choices - a relevant topic today.

Arena Forum:
Civil Dialogues Series Starts March 2018
To provide an opportunity to engage in civil discourse about social and political issues, and will demonstrate-with the goal-that people of diverse viewpoints can have fruitful dialogues with one another.
(Please see links to more information and a link to the first forum streaming video on CSpan below)
There are knowledgeable panelists from  a range of backgrounds and points of views
_________________________________________________________________________
The first forum is not too academic, scholarly or wonk. Etzioni is almost prophetic when the chosen subjects of this public discourse have hit the news  now - Facebook/Cambridge Analytics, encryption technology and email privacy, GPS/Geo-tech tracking, data merchants, surveillance without borders and others. The hour-and-a-half go by quickly when your attention span is extended.
One item grabbed my attention when brought up by the moderator: Clear Choice.


_________________________________________________________________________________
Modern Surveillance Privacy on CSpan | 26 March 2018
1 https://www.c-span.org/video/?443054-1/lawyers-discuss-privacy-concerns-modern-era 
2 https://archive.org/details/CSPAN_20180328_054600_Modern_Surveillance__Privacy
_______________________________________________________________________________
Arena Forum: Civil Dialogues Series Starts March 2018
The conversations seek to provide an opportunity for members of the Washington, D.C. community to engage in civil discourse about social and political issues, and will demonstrate-with the goal-that people of diverse viewpoints can have fruitful dialogues with one another. Each Arena Forum will have a group of prominent Dialogue Starters and will be moderated by Amitai Etzioni, a University Professor at The George Washington University and author.
The first Arena Forum on March 26 will tackle 'exploring the thesis that surveillance is excessive and privacy is endangered by both the government and by private corporations.' The Dialogue Starters that evening will include Julie Brill, ?Corporate Vice President and Deputy General Counsel at Microsoft and former Commissioner of the U.S. Federal Trade Commission; Matthew Olsen, Harvard Law School and former General Counsel for the National Security Agency?; Jeffrey Rosen?, President and CEO of the National Constitution Center and former legal editor the New Republic; Gabe Rottman, Washington director for PEN America and former Legislative Counsel and Policy Advisor at the American Civil Liberties Union; and Peter Swire?, Professor of Law and Ethics at the Georgia Tech Scheller College of Business and former White House coordinator.
more information : www.arenastage.org/forum
_________________________________________________________________________________
RELATED CONTENT:
Story image for amitai etzioni modern surveillance privacy from The Atlantic
The Atlantic-Mar 9, 2015
I join with those who hold that some surveillance is justified, as long as it is in line with laws enacted by Congress and guidelines approved by the courts, and the implementation of these measures is properly supervised by independent oversight authorities such as inspectors general, the Privacy and Civil ...
 
Story image for Clear Choice data broker from Infosecurity Magazine
Infosecurity Magazine-Aug 15, 2017
I embarked on an analysis of data broker sites to examine what kind of security was in place for data brokers with a web presence. ... in a man-in-the-middle position has effectively nullified the encryption since he can sniff the cookie in clear and ride your encrypted session all the way (it's the same cookie).
 
Jun 22, 2017 - Because the modern Internet is agnostic to national borders, purely domestic communications can pass through foreign countries—where they are ..... The remainder of this report considers surveillance that is not “intentionally targeted,” yet nevertheless still significantly implicates the privacy of Americans
 
Apr 25, 2016 - After the deal, Mark Zuckerberg boasted: “We believe the Atlas platform will help us demonstrate even more clearly the connection between ad ... The data brokers. News coverage about mass surveillance today generally focuses on the issue of bulk data collection — but Facebook's ventures in the ...
 

28 March 2018

Avoiding The Words 'Toxic Discharges' Into Wastewater Treatment Plants

WTFark are they talking about?????
City Council Report 
Date:  March 19, 2018
To:  City Council Through: Karolyn Kent, Assistant City Manager
From:  Jake West, Water Resources Department Director 
Subject: Approving and Adopting an Amendment to the City Code regarding sewer use and mass based discharge limitations for industrial users. (Citywide)  



Purpose and Recommendation 
The City of Mesa City Code Section 8-4-15: Prohibited Substances and Discharge Limitations, currently does not specifically provide for the use of mass based limits (pounds per day) in lieu of concentration base limits (milligrams per liter) for pollutants of concern for designated industrial users. 
The Water Resources Department recommends that the Mesa City Council approve the incorporation of a specific provision regarding use of mass based limits.  

Background and Discussion 
Recently, the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ) performed a Pretreatment Compliance Inspection (PCI) of Mesa’s Sewer Use Ordinance - found in the Mesa City Code at Title 8, Chapter 4. 

One item that ADEQ raised as a result of the inspection was that the Code does not specifically provide for the use of mass based limits in lieu of concentration based discharge limits for designated industrial users.   
Establishing a specific provision for the use of mass based limits will potentially allow industrial users to increase manufacturing

BLOGGER NOTE:
And discharges of toxic waste into the city's water treatment plants - this is a cost

More jargon >
The use of equivalent mass based limits in lieu of concentration-based limits will allow the industrial user more flexibility to implement water conservation, as

they may elect to control their process wastewater through: 
1. more efficient technologies and pollution prevention practices
 (e.g. resulting in lower pollutant concentrations in the discharged wastewater) or
2. more efficient water conservation practices
(e.g. resulting in less wastewater volume discharged from the industrial operations)
3. or both. 
Mass based limits also allow the City additional options when considering the industrial loading at the water reclamation plants > See Budget Pie
  
Alternatives 
Mesa could decide not to approve the purposed recommendations, but may limit the City’s use of mass based limits for industrial users. 
Fiscal Impact 
There is no anticipated fiscal impact to the City.