27 April 2023

TECHDIRT: Tough Love for AT&T | Karl Bode

This is a company that has absolutely adored hoovering up subsidies and then running off into the wilderness leaving network upgrades half completed, often with absolutely zero accountability. It’s also a company that’s repeatedly not only been caught ripping off its own customers, but repeatedly ripping off the government and the education system (despite being a trusted NSA ally)...

AT&T Shoves Long Neglected DSL Customers To Wireless, Insists That’s Good Enough

from the half-assery dept

"A few years ago AT&T, a company that tried to cheap out on upgrading its broadband lines to fiber, effectively stopped selling DSL. While that’s understandable given the dated copper-based tech, the problem is that thanks to concentrated telecom monopolization, many of these customers were left without any replacement options due to a lack of competition.

There are other issues at play too. AT&T has, for decades, received countless billions in tax cuts, subsidies, merger approvals, and regulatory favors (remember how killing net neutrality, broadbandprivacy rules, or approving a wave of doomed mergers were all supposed to unleash untold innovation, job creation, and network expansion? Yeah, AT&T doesn’t either).

They’ve also lobbied relentlessly to crush small telecom operators that dared to compete with it. And they’ve consistently been subsidized by the government to keep older copper lines (still heavily used by the nation’s elderly to call their grandkids or 911) in service. All the while, they’ve been found repeatedly guilty of “redlining” — or refusing to upgrade poor and minority neighborhoods to fiber despite untold billions in government assistance.

✓ Three years after unceremoniously hanging up on them, and AT&T is finally shoving its long-neglected DSL customers to alternative options: namely, wireless technology that’s still not really a full symmetrical equivalent of fiber. Not all of these neglected customers get the option; only ones that live in areas where AT&T has adequately upgraded its wireless network:

AT&T is currently offering Internet Air to a limited set of copper-based customers in places where AT&T has wireless coverage and capacity to deliver a “high-quality” customer experience, a spokesperson told Fierce.

This is, of course, better than nothing. Especially at $55 a month (plus various, obnoxious fees). But it’s still not really the functional equivalent of the fiber networks AT&T repeatedly promised it would deliver all Americans in exchange for a rotating crop of massive subsidies and government favors. Like, say, the $42 billion Trump tax cut the company falsely claimed would create jobs...

This is a company that has absolutely adored hoovering up subsidies and then running off into the wilderness leaving network upgrades half completed, often with absolutely zero accountability. It’s also a company that’s repeatedly not only been caught ripping off its own customers, but repeatedly ripping off the government and the education system (despite being a trusted NSA ally).

As it stands, there are still “carrier of last resort” laws in some states (like California) that make it difficult for AT&T to disconnect older phone and DSL customers who depend on cheaper access to 911. AT&T lobbyists have been busy for years nibbling away at those requirements, effectively stating that less reliable, slower, patchy (and often throttled, something AT&T has a history of lying about) wireless connections are effectively “good enough.”

You’ll notice how the telecom trade magazine linked above mentions… absolutely none of this.

Someday wireless will be a symmetrical replacement for fiber, but it absolutely isn’t yet, despite endless telecom giant pretense to the contrary. Shoving these long-neglected DSL customers at wireless (if they’re lucky) after being paid untold billions to upgrade them to fiber is something countless captured state and federal telecom policymakers would very much love to memory hole.

Filed Under: , , , , , , , , ,
Companies: at&

 

Older Stuff
09:35 Like The Social Dilemma Did, The AI Dilemma Seeks To Mislead You With Misinformation (27)
05:23 One More Time With Feeling: The GOP Never Seriously Supported 'Antitrust Reform' Or Monopoly Busting (21)
19:45 N.H. Bakery's Mural Causes Town Beuracrats To Go Nuts Over Donuts (17)
15:48 Ninth Circuit Says A Horn Honk Isn't Protected Political Expression Even When That's The Honk's Entire Point (18)
13:46 Two Excellent Podcast Episodes Techdirt Readers Might Like (1)
12:14 Once Again, Epic Fails In Its Antitrust Quest Against Apple (6)
11:04 Forbes 30 Under 30… And Facing 30 Years Behind Bars (10)
10:59 Daily Deal: Flux 7 TWS Earbuds with Wireless Charging Case And Power Bank (0)
09:29 Canadian Court Allows Distance Learning Spyware Seller To Continue Silencing One Of Its Many Critics (11)
05:28 FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr Continues To Enjoy Oodles Of Free Press For Fear Mongering About TikTok (4)
19:56 DEA's Fentanyl Narrative Clown Car Being Overseen By A 'Reformer' Who Replaced Old Corruption With Her Own Brand Of Corruption (10)
15:45 Red Cross Continues To Want To Pretend That Video Game Wars Are IRL Wars (36)
13:47 US-Located Chinese Cop Shops Allegedly Targeted People For Comparing President Xi To Winnie The Pooh (10)
12:04 Senator Durbin’s ‘STOP CSAM Act’ Has Some Good Ideas… Mixed In With Some Very Bad Ideas That Will Do More Harm Than Good (14)
10:57 New York Court Rules State Police Can't Keep Hiding Its Misconduct Records From The Public (4)
10:52 Daily Deal: Ableton Music Production Mastery Bundle (1)
09:35 Elon Seems To Think The Cruelest Thing He Can Do To People… Is To Pretend They Want To Associate With Him (108)
05:33 Dumb State Laws Blocking Community Broadband Could Mar Historic Subsidy Efforts (4)
12:00 Funniest/Most Insightful Comments Of The Week At Techdirt (9)
12:05 This Week In Techdirt History: April 16th - 22nd (1)
19:39 Israeli Phone Malware Maker QuaDream Apparently Ready To Call It Quits After Suffering A Little Negative Press (7)
15:29 Nintendo Goes To War With YouTubers Right Before New 'Zelda' Release (56)
13:26 Texas School Serves Up Magnificent Redaction Failure To Vice Journalist (19)
12:03 Stability AI And DeviantArt Ask Court To Dismiss Artists' Silly Lawsuit Against Generative Art (147)
10:49 German Legislator Sends Cops To Literally Police Twitter For Porn (11)
10:46 Daily Deal: The All-in-One American Sign Language Bundle (1)
09:33 Lying Liar George Santos Just As Wrong About Section 230 As He Is About His Own Biography (28)
05:27 Netflix To End DVD Rentals As Streaming Fails To Live Up To Its Full Potential (38)
19:59 Bethesda Does Denuvo Backwards: Puts The DRM On Game Released A Year Ago (16)
15:30 Bluesky Plans Decentralized Composable Moderation (83)
More arrow

No comments:

The Complete Bart Simpson Timeline