Saturday, June 13, 2026

TIME TO GET IT RIGHT > LOOKING BACK TO INFAMOUS SITE 17...Vacant for decades, will downtown Mesa project finally see new life?

Culdesac aims to revamp downtown Mesa's Site 17.




October 2023

New plans pitched for tortured downtown site | News | themesatribune.com

11 May 2021

Holey Holdings! Sizzle or Fizzle

Don't know if you noticed or not but Miravista Holdings LLC happens to be all over some 
places in Mesa.
Miravista Holdings (https://www.miravistaholdings.com/ ) is a boutique development firm 
specializing in Brownfield redevelopment, urban infill, and adaptive re-use projects.
Here's a story from three weeks ago - curiously enough featuring former Mesa Mayor 
Scott Smith and his "vision". . . for that wrecking-ball decades-old disaster infamous Site 17: 


What to do with Site 17?

SPOTLIGHT 

It's the result of bad urban planning when city officials only listened to real estate developer speculation schemes that demolished more than 60 homes to destroy a neighborhood leaving 27 acres vacant, ugly and un-used and it's city-owned. City officials now own the damage done and have hired a group of consultants who tried to transform a part of downtown Gilbert's Heritage Area.
The history here on this infamous site - and all the problems - simply cannot be ignored now. . . Jeff McVay, the city's so-called "Director of Downtown Transformation" failed miserably two years wasting time-and-money on citizen input sessions that got nowhere.
Did the community already provide input on this site?
_________________________________________________________________________
BLOGGER NOTE: I only attended one of the workshops two years ago, observing the domination and control by the Mesa Grande/ANA (Action Neighborhood Alliance).
Likewise, once again, at the Steering Committee the same complaint was voiced for actions by the Mesa Grande/ANA (Action Neighborhood Alliance)
_________________________________________________________________________
 Yes! There were two community meetings and a survey conducted in the summer of 2016. After those meetings, Mesa City Council asked that a consultant be hired to create conceptual master plans for the property with more community input. The consultant, Crandall Arambula, was hired in September 2018 and has received all of the input from 2016 for review.

This is their promise to fulfill the ____ contract:
“We will provide the Mesa community with maximum value for investment. We are passionate about assisting communities through our depth of experience and research, and we are committed to the long-term success of this project. The measure of that success will ultimately be the development of a vibrant community that is harmonious with greater Downtown Mesa. We look forward to working with you.”
________________________________________________________________

What makes your MesaZona blogger turn red is this statement just a few days ago made by Mesa Mayor John Giles: 
"The city is not in the business of owning remnant, undeveloped pieces of properties, . . . " 
WTF????
How wrong can Giles get spouting bullshit like that with blinders on when Site 17 has been an ugly eyesore for more than 30 years. He sees only what he wants to see and lacks any vision whatsoever unless it's fed to as bait.
_________________________________________________________________________

Some people who attended the first presentation have told me they were "disappointed" and that's putting it mildly to say the least!
Here's a link to the workshop six weeks ago where attendees were told to only submit written comments: https://www.mesaaz.gov/about-us/city-projects/downtown-transformation/university-mesa 
Slick-and-slippery: The Process

Hope again for long-dormant downtown parcel | News | eastvalleytribune.com 

29 March 2022

STIGMATIZED INFAMOUS SITE 17: A Relic of Downtown Bulldozing + Bad Urban Land-Use Planning

Intro: It was and is a recurring wrecking-ball wreck leaving behind a vacant 27-acre scar all in the name of urban renewal when the city of Mesa seized the properties using Eminent Domain.
It was a futile attempt to "whitewash" segregation in the neighborhood named North Town, next to Rendezvous Park.
However it came to be known as The Mesa Verde Resort Debacle
30 years ago the City of Mesa spent $6,000,000 to demolish a neighborhood that created a "wrecking-ball nightmare.
This public statement made last year:
"The City of Mesa wishes to transform 27 acres of city-owned land at the SWC of University and Mesa Drive into 'a vibrant and cohesive urban mixed-use project' and is requesting a partner to help with that vision . . ."

NICE SPIN ON THAT LIP-SERVICE at the same time city officials were talking with Salt Lake City developers for years.
According to the RFQ, “At 27-acres, this site would be the largest parcel to be developed in the downtown area and could be the largest single development opportunity within downtown for many years to come.”
 
 featured top story

Can city boondoggle be a downtown boon?

   

City planners laid out their vision of how residential, commercial and office space would be distributed on the downtown site. (City of Mesa) +

Boondoggle

Updated

"Mesa City Council hopes this is the year to finally turn a downtown boondoggle into a boon for downtown. Council recently heard the latest development plan for 27 acres of city-owned land just north of Main Street near Phoenix Marriott Mesa that Mesa acquired through eminent domain, leveling 63 homes at a taxpayer cost of $6 million.


INSERT: Excerpt from earlier post

WHAT HAPPENED?

Developer Requested to Transform Mesa Site

If Mesa succeeds in bringing the long-dreamed redevelopment into reality with the city’s latest partner on the project, Miravista Holdings, it would make the third decade the charm for a prime piece of real estate that has long sat vacant.

  • The city started purchasing property at the southwest corner Mesa and University Drives in 1996 and eventually acquired homes through eminent domain in order to make way for a 12-story water-park resort proposed by a Canadian developer.
  • But the planned Mesa Verde water resort died after the developer failed to secure funding.

Since then, city planners have envisioned different types of projects for Site 17, as it’s been known, and hoped one developer after another would take up the mantle; but those deals all fell through. . .city planners are hoping 2022 is the year an agreement with a developer leads to shovels in the ground. 

> Last year, the city signed a nine-month “exclusive dealings agreement” with Miravista Holdings to create a master plan for the parcel, which commands a critical location that is in walking distance from downtown attractions, light rail and the Arizona State University campus.

> Officials appeared cautiously optimistic that the multi-phase, mixed use development concocted by Miravista and architectural firm Gensler will come to fruition and keep the redevelopment project only on the drawing board for a fourth decade. . .

No comments:

South China Morning Post: Clippings

  Diplomacy China accuses US of power abuse with expanded blacklist of Chinese firms Washington is using national security as a cover for it...