Lander’s arrest was so out of line that even his rivals in the city’s
upcoming mayoral primary had to defend him. Among them was prince of
darkness Andrew Cuomo, who weighed in thusly:
This is the latest example of the
extreme thuggery of Trump’s ICE out of control—one can only imagine the
fear families across our country feel when confronted with ICE. Fear of
separation, fear of being taken from their schools, fear of being
detained without just cause. This is not who we are. This must stop, and
it must stop now.
On the surface, Cuomo’s response is just about hitting the required
beats. This is bad, it has to end—yes, all true. But there’s one phrase
that jumps out: “out of control.”
Abolishing ICE Is the Bare Minimum
ICE agents aren’t out of control. They are performing their designed role as fascism’s storm troopers.
Immigration
and Customs Enforcement (ICE) arrest New York City Comptroller Brad
Lander outside of federal immigration court on Tuesday, June 17, 2025,
in New York.
(Olga Fedorova / AP Photo)
. . .The implication is that ICE has somehow slipped the bonds of
respectability and is rampaging around with no supervision. Nobody’s
minding the store! Everything’s chaos! Where are the rule followers!?
But this isn’t what ICE looks like when it’s “out of control.” It’s what ICE looks like when it’s in control—when
it’s doing the job that it has been asked to do. That job, more or
less, is to be the chief enforcement arm of US fascism.
And that’s why the agency should be torn down—and why abolishing ICE
must be part of the platform of any politician who identifies as a
progressive or leftist in this country. If you’re watching what’s
happening right now and not demanding that this structure of repression
be dismantled, you don’t deserve my vote. . .
But if what we’re witnessing right now shows us anything, it’s that
abolishing ICE remains as important as ever. Not only that—it is an
obvious litmus test for anyone seeking political office.
You can’t
proclaim to fight Trumpist extremism and dodge its most visible,
horrifying manifestation.
You can’t run for local office as a
progressive and collaborate with this project.
You can’t vote to fund it
and expect grassroots support.
You can’t say you’re a supporter of
immigrants and fail to stand up to their tormentors.
This isn’t a wild ask. It’s the least we should expect. Anything less is unacceptable. Anything less is a win for fascism.