02 September 2023

Open-Ended: Phillips Payson O’Brien writes in The Atlantic, "The U.S. and Europe Are Splitting Over Ukraine" . . .The GOP's populist wing would abandon Kyiv—and endanger the world's most successful military alliance.

OK that is one statement made based on a supposition from the source whose point-of-view goes back to Allied victories in the 20th Century. (see below)

NATO: the most dangerous military alliance on the planet – Canadian  Dimension


Context: Phillips Payson O’Brien is a professor of strategic studies at the University of St. Andrews in Scotland. 

The U.S. and Europe Are Splitting Over Ukraine

The GOP’s populist wing would abandon Kyiv—and endanger the world’s most successful military alliance.

The American flag, but a European yellow star is peeling off of a white star

The American flag, but a European yellow star is peeling off of a white star

Illustration by Paul Spella / The Atlantic
Europe and the United States are on the verge of the most momentous conscious uncoupling in international relations in decades. 
  • Since 1949, NATO has been the one constant in world security. Initially an alliance among the United States, Canada, and 10 countries in Western Europe, NATO won the Cold War and has since expanded to include almost all of Europe. 
  • It has been the single most successful security grouping in modern global history. 
  • It also might collapse by 2025.
The cause of this collapse would be the profound difference in outlook between the Republican Party’s populist wing—which is led by Donald Trump but now clearly makes up the majority of the GOP—and the existential security concerns of much of Europe. 
The immediate catalyst for the collapse would be the war in Ukraine. 
  • When the dominant faction within one of the two major American political parties can’t see the point in helping a democracy-minded country fight off Russian invaders, that suggests that the center of the political spectrum has shifted in ways that will render the U.S. a less reliable ally to Europe. The latter should prepare accordingly. . .

_

The U.S. and Europe Are Splitting Over Ukraine - The Atlantic
Ukraine-Russia War: A prelude to a post-Western international order? -  Institute for Security and Development Policy
Long read: The World's Most Successful Alliance — 70 years of freedom | by  Ministry of Defence | Voices Of The Armed Forces | Medium

_

Many predicted Nato expansion would lead to war. Those warnings were  ignored | Ted Galen Carpenter | The Guardian

_________________________________________________________________________________

Excerpt:
NATO’s new command structure with additional headquarters aims to accomplish a better capability of deploying troops. 
Do you think the potential deterrence towards Russia deriving from this step goes far enough?
It reflects the forward leaning adaptive nature of our great Alliance. I am impressed with both of the major command changes that have been proposed. 
  • And, I hope that Germany is the country that takes the lead on this. 
  • Particularly the rear area operations command
  • That is a logical choice from geography as well as capability and their organizational skills. 
  • It would do an awful lot to improve our ability to receive reinforcements as well as to move allied formations across Europe.
Michael E. O’Hanlon, a Senior Fellow at the Brookings Institution, supports the hypothesis that the end of NATO’s eastward expansion and the implementation of a zone of neutral nations would reduce tensions with Russia. 
How do you assess this proposal?

I believe nations get to make their own choices. 
  • If those nations want to join the EU and they meet the criteria then they should be able to join the EU.
  •  If they want to join the Alliance and they meet the criteria and the Alliance accepts it, then they should be able to do it. 
  • So, that is what we are all about, the self-determination of sovereign nations.

___________________________________________________________________________________

VIDEO

The United States, as NATO's largest military power, stationed materiel and tens of thousands of troops across Europe to support the defence of Western Europe.
NATO.int · NATO History · Feb 13, 2019
NATO is the most successful military alliance in history. Germany is making its contribution and honours its obligations.
YouTube · GermanyDiplo · Apr 5, 2019
While the signing of the North Atlantic Treaty had created Allies, it had not created a military structure that could effectively coordinate ...
NATO.int · NATO History · Jun 3, 2022
"Without question, NATO has been the most successful military alliance in human history," Milley said. "And NATO is still very much a vital ...
Department of Defense · Jul 15, 2021
2.1 A political and military Alliance ... Security in our daily lives is key to our well-being. NATO's purpose is to guarantee the freedom and security of its ...
NATO.int · NATO · Apr 9, 2009
"We will repair our alliances and engage with the world once again ... down in Afghanistan ending the alliance's largest military operation.
Department of Defense · Jun 7, 2021
The North Atlantic Treaty was signed in 1949 as a defensive military alliance between the US, Canada and ten western European states. At the ...
The Week UK · The Week Staff · May 20, 2022


___________________________________________________________________________________

NATO: The World's Most Powerful Military Alliance or Obsolete? | The  National Interest

__

Except Abdelkader didn't have the greatest military alliance in the world  backing him with weapons and led his cavalry to battle alone against a  superpower. The comparison is an insult to Emir
List of military alliances - Wikipedia
Hodges: “NATO is the most successful Alliance in world history” -  Atlantik-Brücke e.V.
Every Military Alliance Explained: All Of The World's Alliances - TLDR News  - YouTube
Map of major military alliances in the world : r/MapPorn
NATO Defense Spending: How Much Does Each Country Contribute?



_____________________________________________________________________________________

No comments:

Centrifugal Hyper-Gravity and Interdisciplinary Experiment Facility >> China turns on hyper-gravity machine to ‘compress’ time and space

The world's most advanced hypergravity machine - capable of generating forces thousands of times greater than Earth's surface gravit...