Ethiopia Fails to Pay Coupon, Becoming Latest African Defaulter

FORBEARANCE: Ethiopia’s largest single creditor, China, allowed the East African country to suspend debt repayments on bonds maturing in the 2023-24 fiscal year.

Ethiopia failed to pay a $33m bond coupon on Monday and looks set to become the latest African country to default on its debt unless a restructuring agreement can be found with international bondholders within the 14-day grace period. Only two weeks ago, the governor of the National Bank of Ethiopia told the Ethiopian parliament that the country had secured over $1.5bn in temporary debt relief from its international creditors, leading to speculation that Ethiopia would avoid default. Earlier this year, Ethiopia’s largest single creditor, China, allowed the East African country to suspend debt repayments on bonds maturing in the 2023-24 fiscal year. Ethiopia also has relatively low levels of external debt compared to other countries which have defaulted. But Ethiopia’s finance ministry said on Friday it was “not in a position to pay” the $33m coupon because of the nation’s “fragile external position.”

AFRICAN BUSINESS

December 25, 2023 at 8:26 AM MST

Ethiopia became Africa’s latest defaulter after it failed to make an interest payment following the end of a grace period on Monday. The Horn of Africa nation had to pay a $33 million coupon on Dec. 11. The government didn’t want to make the payment because it “wants to treat all creditors in the same way,” Ahmed Shide, Ethiopia’s minister of finance said on state TV on Thursday.

“It appears that the country is funding its growth through the issuance of securities denominated in the currencies of other countries.

I would surmise that they are currently experiencing problems due to interest rates rising on this debt as central banks raise rates to tackle inflation. This is a problem we often see in developing economies.”

December 13th, 2023Image : Zerophoto

Ethiopia failed to pay a $33m bond coupon on Monday and looks set to become the latest African country to default on its debt unless a restructuring agreement can be found with international bondholders within the 14-day grace period. A call is scheduled for Thursday with Ethiopia’s creditors to try and find a last-ditch agreement, but markets now expect Ethiopia to join Zambia and Ghana as Africa’s latest debt defaulters.

✓ Only two weeks ago, the governor of the National Bank of Ethiopia told the Ethiopian parliament that the country had secured over $1.5bn in temporary debt relief from its international creditors, leading to speculation that Ethiopia would avoid default.

✓ Earlier this year, Ethiopia’s largest single creditor, China, allowed the East African country to suspend debt repayments on bonds maturing in the 2023-24 fiscal year. Ethiopia also has relatively low levels of external debt compared to other countries which have defaulted.

But Ethiopia’s finance ministry said on Friday it was “not in a position to pay” the $33m coupon because of the nation’s “fragile external position.”

Hailemelekot Berhan, a capital markets in analyst in Addis Ababa, tells African Business that “Ethiopia is not really a debt distressed country” and the looming default is therefore likely the result of a breakdown in communication with private bondholders.

“It seems that Ethiopia has concluded restructuring agreements with Paris Club members and China, but private bondholders and international investors have not agreed to the same terms,” he says.

“This situation may have come about because of insufficient or ineffective communication with these bondholders. Government officials working in this area may not have the appropriate knowledge or experience of going about these things.”

However, Philip Pilkington, an investment professional and senior research analyst at GMO in London, notes that this default may be the result of Ethiopia’s “consistent current account deficits” and high exposure to international debt markets.

✓ “I have noticed that Ethiopia has lower external debt ratios than they have had in the past, but that said, the country has run consistent current account deficits since the mid-1990s and in recent years these have become large and consistent,” Pilkington tells African Business.

A dent to Ethiopia’s capital-raising hopes

While the precise cause of the default is disputed, Berhan fears that the situation could severely dent Ethiopia’s hopes to attract foreign capital – and could even undermine Abiy Ahmed’s long-term liberalisation plans.

“Ethiopia is not particularly debt burdened and the repayment amount of $33m is very small. But the consequence of a default nonetheless is that investors are going to get really worried,” he says. “The government is liberalising sectors like finance and gearing towards attracting foreign direct investment, but it is very tough to do that successfully when the country is defaulting.”

Pilkington is also concerned about Ethiopia’s economic trajectory in light of the default. “The worst-case scenario is that the large increases in per capita GDP Ethiopia has seen in the last decade or so might be reversed, as markets stop allowing them to fund their large current account deficits,” he argues. “But all this will depend on how the situation is managed.”

Geopolitical implications

He adds that the default could have significant geopolitical as well as economic implications for Ethiopia – and believes that there is now an opportunity for BRICS countries “to offer members financing on friendlier and less punitive terms than the International Monetary Fund (IMF)”.

“When Ethiopia joined the BRICS, it was already clear that they were having financial difficulties,” he says.
“I would infer from this that the BRICS leaders are aware that Ethiopia is likely facing down a crisis – and this leads me to wonder if they have a strategy to deal with this that will further the goals of the BRICS.

“What we can say is that just after Ethiopia joined the BRICS in August, China suspended payments on its debt and Ethiopia is now using the China deal as a template for negotiations with other creditors.

This highlights that, at the very least, the new BRICS formation is introducing ‘competition’ into geo-economic relations. This is an important development.”

Default Countdown

Reserved for subscribers

Posted on December 12, 2023 11:27

Ethiopia’s Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed (L) is shown the way by Chinese President Xi Jinping before their meeting at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing, China, April 24, 2019. Parker Song/Pool via Reuters

Lack of transparency rather than unsustainable debts lies behind Ethiopia’s missed Eurobond coupon payment.

Ethiopia’s failure to meet a scheduled coupon payment on its $1bn 2024 Eurobond on 11 December shows that mechanisms for communication on sovereign debt distress aren’t fit for purpose.

There's more to this story...

Get unlimited access to our exclusive journalism and features today. Our award-winning team of correspondents and editors report from over 54 African countries, from Cape Town to Cairo, from Abidjan to Abuja to Addis Ababa. Africa. Unlocked.

Remittances flow to Sub-Saharan African countries estimated to have reached $54 Billion in 2023, showing a slight increase from the gain last year.

The increase was driven by strong remittance growth in

Mozambique (48.5%),
Rwanda (16.8%), and
Ethiopia (16%), the World Bank says today.

Also read: Australia’s growing footprint in Africa’s mining sector

Its latest Migration and Development Brief estimates remittance inflow to the region to show a 1.9% growth from $53 billion in 2022 to $54 billion this year.

The slowed growth is explained by the slow pace of growth in the high-income economies where many Africans earn their income.

Still, the report notes that remittance inflow surpassed the foreign direct investment (FDI) and official development assistance (ODA) flows.

“Remittances are one of the few sources of private external finance that are expected to continue to grow in the coming decade,” Dilip Ratha, lead author of the report, said.
“They must be leveraged for private capital mobilization to support development finance, especially via diaspora bonds.”

SS Africa’s top three recipients

The largest recipients of remittances in the region during 2022 – measured in US dollar terms – include Nigeria, Ghana, and Kenya.

Also read: UK Ebury enters Africa’s fintech with Prime Finance Markets acquisition

The same countries dominate the top three recipients this year too.
Nigeria is expected to receive more than $20 billion in official remittances by the end of 2023, showing a 2% increase from last year.
Ghana and Kenya posted estimated gains of 5.6% and 3.8%, respectively.In terms of its share of GDP, the Gambia has the largest share, followed by Lesotho, Comoros, Cabo Verde, Guinea-Bissau, and Zimbabwe.

Remittance Inflow to continue Growing in 2024

Remittances to Sub-Saharan Africa will keep increasing next year albeit at a slow pace.

World Bank’s report projects the remittances to the region to reach $55 billion by 2024 but says there are risks to this outlook including measures to control foreign exchange, parallel markets, and sanctions.

The cautious projection comes amid fixed exchange rates and capital controls continue to divert remittances to the region from official to unofficial channels.

Also read: UAE makes play for Africa renewables

Globally, the concern is the risk of a decline in real income for migrants in 2024 in the face of global inflation and low growth prospects.

FurtherAfrica

Founded in 2015 FurtherAfrica is an online platform centralising news and content focusing on the development and growth story of the African continent

MesaZona > Table of Contents : Here's The Menu. Enjoy

25 December 2023