08 February 2023

Huh? 'Moral Panic' in Mesa Public Schools ...Suing Social Media for Youth Mental Health Crisis

 


The Mesa Public Schools Governing Board gave the green light on Tuesday to allow its lawyers to work with outside attorneys to file a multidistrict lawsuit against companies like Facebook, TikTok and YouTube. This is just one of many steps before an official lawsuit is filed.

16 hours ago · Last week, we wrote about the positively ridiculous lawsuit filed by the Seattle Public School district against basically all of social ...


Jan 26, 2023 · The Mesa Public Schools District is seeking to take social media companies to court over practices they consider harmful to the mental ...


". . Like the Seattle complaint, it posts a few cherry-picked studies claiming that social media is bad for kids, and ignores more comprehensive studies that argue that opposite. Like the Seattle complaint, it goes hard in proving that Mesa public schools apparently are staffed by administrators and teachers who suck at educating children, and find themselves powerless against… entertainmen

In short, it’s pathetic.

The one main “difference” between the Seattle complaint and the Mesa one is that in Mesa they’ve added a “negligence” claim, saying that social media companies “owe” the school district “a duty not to expose Plaintiff to an unreasonable risk of harm….”

 

This is all laughably stupid, and not at all how the law works

www.techdirt.com

Now Mesa Public Schools Are Also Declaring That They Have Failed In Educating Their Children By Suing Social Media

Tue, Feb 7th 2023 12:09pm - Mike Masnick
3 - 4 minutes

from the this-makes-it-a-trend dept

"Last week, we wrote about the positively ridiculous lawsuit filed by the Seattle Public School district against basically all of social media claiming social media was “a public nuisance.” As we noted, the school district appeared to be wasting taxpayer money, that could have gone to educating their kids, on this lawsuit that screamed out to the public that the school district had totally failed in educating their children how to be good digital citizens, how to use the internet properly, and how to be prepared for living life in the age of the internet.

And, now it appears that the Mesa, Arizona school district has decided to do the same thing. Using the same lawyers. The law offices of Keller Rohrback appears to be trying to carve out this corner of the market as their own: having public school districts waste a shitload of time and resources to publicly proclaim that they can’t prepare the children they’re in charge of educating for the modern internet world.


The Mesa complaint is, not surprisingly, similar to the Seattle complaint. It’s suing the same companies (really: Meta, Google, Snap, Tiktok). Like the Seattle complaint, it argues that social media is a “public nuisance.” Like the Seattle complaint, it says that Section 230 doesn’t protect the companies (it’s wrong). Like the Seattle complaint, it posts a few cherry-picked studies claiming that social media is bad for kids, and ignores more comprehensive studies that argue that opposite. Like the Seattle complaint, it goes hard in proving that Mesa public schools apparently are staffed by administrators and teachers who suck at educating children, and find themselves powerless against… entertainment.


✓ In short, it’s pathetic
.

The one main “difference” between the Seattle complaint and the Mesa one is that in Mesa they’ve added a “negligence” claim, saying that social media companies “owe” the school district “a duty not to expose Plaintiff to an unreasonable risk of harm….”

This is all laughably stupid, and not at all how the law works. I mean, it’s possible that the lawyers at Keller Rohrback figure that if they file enough of these lawsuits, eventually they’ll find a judge who lets the moral panic of “social media is bad for kids” overwhelm the actual legal issues, but it’s difficult to see it standing up to any legitimate judicial scrutiny.

Of course, now that we have these two lawsuits, it means it’s almost certain that they’re shopping for similar lawsuits. One hopes that other school districts will reject this nonsense. The whole point of these lawsuits is almost certainly to try to shake down the social media companies to get them to settle, but that seems unlikely.

Either way, if you’re a parent of a student in the Mesa public schools, you should be asking why your school’s administrators seem to be publicly admitting that they can’t teach your children how to deal with the modern internet world."

Filed Under: , , , ,
Companies: bytedance, facebook, google, instagram, keller rohrback, meta, snapchat, tiktok, youtube 

Jan 26, 2023 · The Mesa Public Schools District is seeking to take social media companies to court over practices they consider harmful to the mental ...

RELATED ARTICLES 

15 hours ago · The law offices of Keller Rohrback appears to be trying to carve out this corner of the market as their own: having public school districts ...
Jan 25, 2023 · The Mesa Public Schools Governing Board voted Tuesday night to file a legal ... 005902 KELLER ROHRBACK L.L.P. 3101 North Central Avenue, ...
Parties, docket activity and news coverage of federal case Mesa Public Schools v. Meta Platforms Incorporated et al, case number 2:23-cv-00172, from Arizona ...
Jan 7, 2023 · On Friday, January 6th, 2023, Seattle Public Schools took the first step towards holding social media companies accountable for the harm ...
Missing: Mesa | Must include:Mesa
Jan 26, 2023 · KELLER ROHRBACK L.L.P. ... E: rkilgard@kellerrohrback.com ... Plaintiff Mesa Public Schools (“Plaintiff” or “MPS”) brings this action to.
On Friday, January 6, 2023, Seattle Public Schools took the first step towards holding social media companies accountable for the harm they have wreaked on ...
Missing: Mesa | Must include:Mesa
Keller Rohrback's attorneys are nationally recognized leaders in litigation. Offices: Seattle, New York, Phoenix, Missoula, Oakland and Santa Barbara.
Missing: Mesa schools
Jan 30, 2023 · ... said a public nuisance and negligence complaint (docket 2:23-cv-172) ... by Mesa Public Schools, the largest public school district in ...

No comments: