Friday, May 20, 2016

It May Be Cooler In Arizona's White Mountains . . . Headlines = Embezzlement, Nepotism, Removal of a Town Manager

Hmmm... perhaps a pre-cautionary tale about dangers and consequent prosecutions with nepotism and "family" connections in government.
More details on SLFD embezzlement
Former chief also being prosecuted; district ‘lacked controls’
Posted: Friday, May 13, 2016 5:00 am | Updated: 4:38 pm, Mon May 16, 2016.
SHOW LOW — Almost four years after Natalie “Tallie” Bingham (formerly Natalie Cluff) was placed on administrative leave for alleged policy violations, the former administrative manager of the Show Low Fire District was arrested, charged with embezzling almost $1.8 million of district funds. 
Bingham is being prosecuted with 21 felony counts related to the embezzlement and submitting fraudulent audits.
According to Bingham, her father, former district chief Ben Owens and former assistant chief (and her then-fiance) “had no knowledge of her actions and were guilty only of trusting her.”
However, the Navajo County Attorney’s Office told The Independent that Owens is being prosecuted for conspiracy, illegally conducting an enterprise, assisting a criminal syndicate and money laundering.
Editor’s note: This statement issued by the Timber Mesa Fire and Medical District following the release of the Auditor General’s report on the embezzlement case involving the former Show Low Fire District is being published unedited and in its entirety.
"The Timber Mesa Fire and Medical District is a special taxing district formed in 2014 as a result of the successful collaboration and the merger of the Lakeside, Show Low and Linden Fire Districts. TMFMD is dedicated to proactive risk reduction efforts, medical services and fire response. We value our community and the public trust we have earned.  Fiscal responsibility and integrity are the cornerstones upon which we are built.
In July of 2012 the Show Low Fire District was made aware that public funds may have been stolen or otherwise misused. The staff at SLFD, led by Chief Randy Chevalier, took the information to the Fire Board who initiated an investigation by multiple third-party consultants. That investigation demonstrated significant financial issues that should be turned over to law enforcement. In August of 2012 the former SLFD employees implicated in the investigation had either retired or resigned . . .
Since the merger in 2014, TMFMD continues to work with law enforcement to see that any person who has handled public funds inappropriately is prosecuted. TMFMD has built upon the financial “best practices” instituted in SLFD.
TMFMD has added safeguards including stringent internal controls, financial policies and strict nepotism policies, etc. In the two years prior to merger SLFD received unremarkable audits indicating any financial concerns had been resolved and all public funds were accounted for. In the two years since merger, TMFMD has also received unremarkable audits. 
On May 10th, 2016 the Auditor General’s office for the State of Arizona released the public report related to the investigative findings of SLFD and those former employees. We encourage members of the public to read the report located at https://www.azauditor.gov/sites/default/files/16-402_Report.pdf. Additionally, an arrest has been made and charges have been levied against those former SLFD employees implicated in the criminal investigation.
 
Pinetop-Lakeside removes town manager
Racette ousted by 5-2 vote
Posted: Friday, April 8, 2016 5:00 am
Bob Martinson The Independent
 
       
 

Follow The Money // Watch Mesa City Council Meeting Mon 05.16.2016

Dear readers, please note that items on the Consent Agenda for council meetings go largely unnoticed and frequently overlooked but usually get approved by voice vote very quickly. In the interest to keep the public informed, here's a listing of contracts with the city with the information provided in the final meeting agenda.

1 Take action on all consent agenda items.

4 Take action on the following contracts:
16-0552 Purchase of Electronic Document Review Equipment for the Development Information Management Enterprise Solution (DIMES) Project for the Information Technology Department (Citywide)
The Development Services Department is launching a new cloud-based DIMES to replace the existing system, Tidemark.  As part of the upgrade, the City will begin providing electronic document review (EDR) for the development community for planning cases and construction plans. EDR will eliminate the vast majority of required physical storage space, document retrieval costs and plan printing costs for the department as well as costs for developers for printing and delivering plans.  Viewing large, detailed plans electronically, requires high definition monitors with greater screen space than is currently available.
The Information Technology and Development Services Departments, and Purchasing recommend authorizing the purchase using the State of Arizona cooperative contract with Dell Marketing, LP, at $146,637.62.  This purchase is funded by the Development Services Technology Fund.
*4-a
16-0551 Three-Year Term Contract for Large Format Commercial Printing for the Business Services Department (Citywide) 
This contract is used to print large format printing projects that Print Services is unable to complete because of a lack of proper equipment or because it is not economically possible to do so.  Printed materials include: flatbed printed items, clings, posters/banners and oversized banners.
The evaluation committee recommends awarding the contract to the highest scored proposals from ARC Document Solutions and Perkinson Reprographics Inc., dba PRI Graphics (a Mesa business), cummulatively not to exceed $96,200 annually, based on estimated requirements.
*4-b
16-0556 One-Year Renewal of the Term Contract for AC Delco and Motorcraft Vehicle Parts for the Fleet Services Department (Citywide)
This contract provides genuine AC Delco (General Motors) and Motorcraft (Ford) parts for the City's fleet.  The fleet consists of approximately 320 Ford automobiles, 285 Ford vans and light trucks, 115 General Motors automobiles and 225 General Motors vans and light trucks.
The Fleet Services Department and Purchasing recommend authorizing a one-year renewal with USD, Inc., at $150,000 annually, based on estimated requirements.
*4-c
Page 3 City of Mesa Printed on 5/12/2016


May 16, 2016City Council Meeting Agenda - Final
16-0553 Purchase of One Replacement Heavy Duty Truck with a Telescopic 55' Pole Setting Derrick and Flatbed Body for the Transportation Department (Single Bid) (Citywide)
The new truck will replace two vehicles that have met established replacement criteria and both will be retired and sold at auction.  
The Fleet Services and Transportation Departments, and Purchasing recommend awarding the contract to the single, responsive and responsible bidder, Altec Industries, Inc., at $227,339.90.  This purchase is funded by Local Street Sales Tax.
*4-d
16-0554 Three-Year Term Contract for Storm Pump Maintenance and Repair for the Transportation Department (Citywide) 
This contract will provide the City with the ability to maintain and repair storm water pumps at various locations throughout the City. 
The Transportation Department and Purchasing recommend awarding the contract to the lowest, responsive and responsible bidders, Precision Electric Company (Primary); and Phoenix Pumps, Inc. (Secondary); at $196,000 annually, based on estimated requirements.  This purchase is funded by the Environmental Compliance Fee.
*4-e
16-0555 Purchase of Infrastructure Equipment to Support Closed-Circuit Television (CCTV) Cameras for the Police Department (Citywide)
The Police Department, Information Technology Division is requesting the purchase of infrastructure items in support of the CCTV upgrade project. Items needed include switching equipment to connect the cameras to the network, dedicated servers to process the video streams, and storage to retain video recordings.  The current video recording solution is analog and fragmented between multiple manufacturers.  A conversion to an enterprise video management system will resolve the current inconsistencies and offer centralized management of video recordings.
The Police and Information Technology Departments, and Purchasing recommend authorizing the purchase using the City of Tucson cooperative contract with CDW-G, at $53,863.88.  This purchase is funded by the 2015 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant.
*4-f
Page 4 City of Mesa Printed on 5/12/2016
May 16, 2016City Council Meeting Agenda - Final
16-0549 Replacement Purchase of Cisco Network Equipment for the Police Department (Citywide) 
Replacement of Mesa Police Department’s existing firewalls is necessary to better guard against modern-day threats and take advantage of next-generation security services for malware and intrusion detection.  The proposed replacement equipment will allow the Police Department to secure its network and ensure the integrity of law enforcement data.
The Police and Information Technology Departments, and Purchasing recommend authorizing the purchase using the State of Arizona contract with Insight Public Sector, at $129,114.66.
*4-g
16-0558 Northwest Water Reclamation Plant - Variable Frequency Drives Replacements and Fiber Loop Project (District 1)
The Northwest Water Reclamation Plant (NWWRP) currently treats an average of 9 million gallons of wastewater per day. The plant is equipped with 30 existing Variable Frequency Drives (VFD).  The VFDs are beyond their useful life and replacing them with newer technology will increase reliability and reduce operating costs. A fiber optic communications loop will also be installed, thereby enhancing security, and increasing reliability.
Staff recommends awarding the project contract to Hunter Contracting, at $2,169,260.35, based on a Guaranteed Maximum Price of $1,972,054.86, plus an additional $197,205.49 (10%) as a change order allowance.  This allowance will only be utilized for City-approved change orders.  Funding is available from the 2010 authorized Wastewater Bond.
*4-h
16-0534 Rio Salado Pathway - SR101L to Dobson Road (District 1)
The City received a federal Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality (CMAQ) grant and a Transportation Alternative (TA) grant to construct a shared-use pathway along the Salt River Bank southern levee that will provide a regional connection to networks in the City of Mesa, City of Tempe and City of Phoenix.  
Staff recommends awarding the project contract to the lowest, responsible bidder, J. Banicki Construction, Inc., in the amount of $3,116,308.50, and authorize a change order allowance in the amount of $311,630 (10%). The project funding is comprised of a $1,599,999 grant from Federal Highway Administration CMAQ, a $1,585,674 grant from Federal Highway Administration TA, and $242,265.50 from the 2012 authorized Parks and Recreation Bond and City of Mesa Transportation Local Street Sales Tax, for
a total amount of $3,427,938.50
*4-i

5 Take action on the following resolutions:
16-0384 Approving and adopting the updated City of Mesa Emergency Operations Plan (EOP) and, consistent with Federal Emergency Management Agency recommendations, authorizing City departments to make non-material modifications to the Plan. (Citywide)
The EOP establishes policies and procedures that enable the City of Mesa to mitigate loss of life, minimize injuries, protect property, preserve a functioning administration, and maintain activities essential to the survival and recovery from natural and man-made hazards.  In addition, it establishes the guidelines for conducting efficient, effective, and coordinated emergency management operations involving all resources available to the City of Mesa.
*5-a
16-0559 Approving and authorizing the City Manager to enter into a Public Highway At-Grade Crossing Improvement Agreement with the Union Pacific Railroad (UPRR) for railroad safety improvements at Alma School Road. (Districts 3 and 4)
This Agreement authorizes Mesa to use and maintain UPRR property to install sidewalk and modify the existing medians at the Alma School Road Crossing.  These improvements and associated costs were approved by Council in November 2015 through an Intergovernmental Agreement with the Arizona Department of Transportation.
*5-b
16-0498 Modifying fees and charges for the Arts and Culture Department. (Citywide)*5-c
16-0499 Modifying fees and charges for the Business Services Department. (Citywide)*5-d
16-0501 Modifying fees and charges for the Development Services Department. (Citywide)
*5-e
16-0502 Modifying fees and charges for the Transportation Department. (Citywide)*5-f
16-0503 Modifying fees and charges for Municipal Court, Transcript Fee. (Citywide)*5-g
16-0535 Approving the FY 2016/2017 Annual Action Plan for submittal to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) and authorizing the City Manager to amend, sign and submit the Annual Action Plan for FY 2016/2017. (Citywide)
*5-h
Page 6 City of Mesa Printed on 5/12/2016
May 16, 2016City Council Meeting Agenda - Final
16-0536 Approving and authorizing the City Manager to prepare, sign and submit applications to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development to receive FY 2016/2017 entitlement funds under the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974 (CDBG), as amended, for City department activities approved by the City Council. (Citywide)
*5-i
16-0537 Approving and authorizing the City Manager to prepare, sign and submit applications to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development to receive FY 2016/2017 entitlement funds under the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974 (CDBG), as amended, for non-profit organization activities approved by the City Council. (Citywide)
*5-j
16-0538 Approving and authorizing the City Manager to prepare, sign and submit applications to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development to receive FY 2016/2017 entitlement funds under the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974 (CDBG), as amended, to fund for-profit organization activities approved by the City Council. (Citywide)
*5-k
16-0539 Approving and authorizing the City Manager to prepare, sign and submit applications to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development to receive FY 2016/2017 entitlement funds under the Stewart B. McKinney Homeless Assistance Act of 1987 (ESG), as amended, for activities approved by the City Council. (Citywide)
*5-l
16-0540 Approving and authorizing the City Manager to prepare, sign and submit applications to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development to receive FY 2016/2017 entitlement funds under the HOME Investment Partnerships program (HOME), as amended, for City department activities approved by the City Council. (Citywide)
*5-m
16-0541 Approving and authorizing the City Manager to prepare, sign and submit applications to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development to receive FY 2016/2017 entitlement funds under the HOME Investment Partnerships program (HOME), as amended, for non-profit organization activities approved by the City Council. (Citywide)
*5-n
16-0542 Approving and authorizing the City Manager to prepare, sign and submit applications to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development to receive FY 2016/2017 entitlement funds under the HOME Investment Partnerships program (HOME), as amended, to fund for-profit organization activities approved by the City Council. (Citywide)
*5-o
Page 7 City of Mesa Printed on 5/12/2016
May 16, 2016City Council Meeting Agenda - Final


8 Discuss, receive public comment, and take action on the following ordinances:
16-0446 Amending Section 9-6-5 of the Mesa City Code increasing sidewalk width requirements to five-feet wide in the Desert Upland Development Standards to be consistent with the required sidewalk widths on local residential streets in the City. (Citywide)
*8-a
16-0500 Amending section 1-12-3 of the Mesa City Code pertaining to the application of the existing Court Sustainability Fee. (Citywide)
*8-b
16-0466 A16-01 (District 1) Annexation of property located north of the Loop 202 Red Mountain Freeway between Gilbert Road and Val Vista Drive (82.9+ acres). This request has been initiated by the City in order to bring a City-owned parcel into the municipal boundaries of Mesa.


16-0543 Approving and authorizing the City Manager to disburse FY 2016/2017 Human Services funds for activities by non-profits approved by the City Council and to enter into agreements for the disbursement of Human Services funds. (Citywide
)

9 Take action on the following subdivision plat:
16-0509 "Eastmark Development Unit 3/4 Parcels 3/4-1 Through 3/4-3" (District 6)  The 9700 through 10000 blocks of East Ray Road (north side), located east of Ellsworth Road and north of Ray Road.  251 PC District - residential lots (51.4± AC.).  DMB Mesa Proving Grounds, LLC, owner; Daniel Hemken, P.E. Hoskin Ryan Consultants, INC., engineer
.



10-b 16-0545 A resolution approving the 2016 District Assessments for Mesa Town Center Improvement District No. 228. For fiscal year 2016/17, the Town Center Improvement District will be assessing 546 parcels at a 3% increase, for a total of $287,262.47.
11-a 16-0547 Conduct a public hearing on modifications to terms/rates/fees/charges of City-owned utilities: items 11-b through 11-h.
11-b 16-0482 An ordinance modifying terms/rates/fees/charges for electric utility services. (Districts 1 and 4)
12-a 16-0548 Conduct a public hearing.
12-b 16-0479 A resolution approving a Five-Year Capital Improvement Program for fiscal years ending 2017-2021. (Citywide)
13 Items from citizens present. (Maximum of three speakers for three minutes per speaker).



http://mesa11.com/vod/?show=1405

Cheat Sheet for Residents/Voters Here In Mesa: What is Nepotism?

Nepotism is a form of discrimination in which family members or friends are hired for reasons that do not necessarily have anything to do with their experience, ...


Strangely enough, according to Wikipedia's definition     Nepotism is favoritism granted to relatives.
The term originated with the assignment of nephews to cardinal positions by Catholic popes and bishops . . .starring as a religion-based practice.
All candidates running campaigns in upcoming elections - this is important - and voters and residents of Mesa might be advised to take a clear look inside city government to root out nepotism.
Those already elected - and those aspiring to enlist public support for election to the Mesa City Council - might think it's a good thing to prove to constituents that you place open and honest government ahead of personal, religious and party loyalties.
Do we need a local anti-nepotism ordinance? Or will politicians come clean?.

nep·o·tism
ˈnepəˌtizəm/
noun
the practice among those with power or influence of favoring relatives or friends, especially by giving them jobs.
"hiring my daughter was not nepotism—it was just good business" [LOL]

Synonyms: favoritism, preferential treatment, the old boy network, looking after one's own,
bias, partiality, partisanship
 
Antonym: impartiality
the unfair practice by a powerful person of giving jobs and other favors to relatives.
Source: Merriam-Webster's Learner's Dictionary
 

Corruption, nepotism and malfeasance is rampant in governments

Sorry, but this doesn't pass the sniff test.
In-laws should be included in anti-nepotism statutes, requiring elected leaders to abstain from votes involving family members.
Anti-nepotism statutes were created as an effort to help clean up government and assure constituents that those in power weren't giving preferential treatment to family members when it came to hiring.
Sadly, political appointments are more about loyalty than getting the best person for the job
 
 




 


 
 
 
job

Take-Aways Here in Mesa for Upcoming Election Season + Past Election Results with Links

City election season gears up
Posted: Thursday, May 19, 2016 6:00 am
The filing period for city and town offices opened May 2, but so far no candidates have filed in any of the three communities [Gilbert, Mesa, and Chandler] in the Southeast Valley 
The filing period closes June 1.
Town clerks say it’s not unusual for candidates to wait until closer to the deadline to file.
All of the positions up for grabs this year are four-year terms.
The Mesa City Council : half of the six members will be replaced in Districts 1, 2, and 3.
In Mesa, three councilmen can’t seek re-election because they’ve been elected twice, the maximum stretch for a person to be on the Mesa City Council.
Exiting the council at the end of the year, according to Mesa City Clerk DeeAnn Mickelson, 
are the following:
Dennis Kavanaugh
Dave Richins
Alex Finter
 
Mesa Mayor: John Giles is hoping to hold on to his seat in the office he's occupied since 2014
Mayor John Giles’ term ends this year, too, but he’s eligible for re-election.
Giles has already announced he’ll run for office and said he plans to officially file on May 23.
 
In Arizona municipal elections, there is no limit to the number of candidates who can run for particular positions in the primary election.
If more than two candidates file for a particular council seat or for mayor, the primary election narrows the field to two candidates per seat who advance to the Nov. 8 general election.
If only one candidate files for any particular seat, the primary election occurs, but no general election is held for that seat.
The deadline to register to vote in the primary election is Aug. 1.
People can register at Maricopa County government offices or local city halls.
Early voting runs from Aug. 3 to Aug. 25.
 
– Contact Shelley Ridenour at 480-898-6533 or sridenour@evtrib.com.                                                                                                                                             






On Your Mark > Get Set > Is Prop 123 A Go?

Bob Robb (correctly) Calls his Colleagues Liars.
It looks like Bob Robb has finally had enough of his colleagues' lies about Prop 123.  Earlier, he charitably asserted that opponents' claims about the legislature misspending the money from Prop 301 or ignoring the courts and voters were "naïve".  Now's he's really calling them out . . .
Read more http://www.espressopundit.com/
 
Robert Robb
Columnist , Opinion                                             
Robert Robb has been an editorial columnist for The Arizona Republic since 1999, and a participant in and observer of Arizona government and politics for nearly four decades.
 

Fair & Balanced > Another View About Contempt of Court + Racial Profiling

Thursday, May 19, 2016
 
Last week, U.S. District Court Judge Murray Snow found Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio and three of his top aides in contempt of court for racial profiling. It could lead to criminal charges. As a former Maricopa County Deputy County Attorney who represented Arpaio on a racketeering case, I do not believe he did anything wrong. He’s an ethical straight-shooter — I don’t believe he’s ever even gotten a speeding ticket. I strongly suspect he’s been targeted for espousing a conservative position in law enforcement, particularly on the defense of our borders.
I also know Arpaio’s former Chief Deputy Jerry Sheridan, included in the judgment, primarily from working with him on Arpaio’s reelection campaign. Like Arpaio, he has a high ethical character, and am convinced he has been targeted for his association with Arpaio.
I have written previously about Judge’s Snow’s proceedings against Arpaio, here andhere. The Department of Justice started investigating Arpaio’s office in 2008 over allegations of racial profiling when arresting illegal immigrants. I’ve written frequently about how the Department of Justice targets prominent conservatives, a practice former DOJ prosecutor Sidney Powell exposes in her book Licensed to Lie. Using the legal system to target conservatives is becoming more and more common, since progressives control much of the judiciary and even many prosecutorial offices.
 

Thursday, May 19, 2016

Mesa 11 Live Stream: City Council Study Session Thu 19 ay 2016 > Heads Up!



http://mesa11.com/vod/?show=1407

City of Mesa
Meeting Agenda - Final
Mesa Council Chambers 57 East First Street


Mayor John Giles Vice Mayor

Dennis Kavanaugh - District 3
Councilmember Dave Richins - District 1
Councilmember Alex Finter - District 2
Councilmember Chris Glover - District 4
Councilmember David Luna - District 5
Councilmember Kevin Thompson - District 6

7:30 AMCouncil Chambers - Lower LevelThursday, May 19, 2016


Roll Call (Members of the Mesa City Council will attend either in person or by telephone conference call)

1 Presentations/Action Items:
16-0575 Hear a presentation, discuss and provide direction on funding options including sales taxes for the following:
1.  Public safety staffing and equipment needs, and the associated costs 2.  Higher education projects and the associated costs
1-a
16-0593 Information pertaining to the current Job Order Contracting projects.2
3 Hear reports on meetings and/or conferences attended.
4 Scheduling of meetings and general information.
5 Convene an Executive Session
.
Page 1 City of Mesa Printed on 5/18/2016
May 19, 2016City Council Study Session Meeting Agenda - Final
ES-003-16 Discussion or consultation for legal advice with the City Attorney. (A.R.S. §38-431.03A (3))  Discussion or consultation with designated representatives of the City in order to consider the City’s position and instruct the City’s representatives regarding negotiations for the purchase, sale, or lease of real property. (A.R.S. §38-431.03A (7))  Discussion or consultation with the City Attorney in order to consider the City’s position and instruct the City Attorney regarding the City’s position regarding contracts that are the subject of negotiations, in pending or contemplated litigation or in settlement discussions conducted in order to avoid or resolve litigation. (A.R.S. §38-431.03A(4))  
1. Intergovernmental Agreement with Arizona State University for a Mesa       campus on City-owned property.
5-a
6 Adjournment.
Any citizen wishing to speak on an agenda item should complete and turn in a blue card to the City Clerk before that item is presented.
The Council may vote to hold an executive session for the purposes of obtaining legal advice from the City Attorney (A.R.S. §38-431.03A(3)) or to discuss and instruct the City Attorney regarding the City’s position regarding contracts that are the subject of negotiations, in pending or contemplated litigation or in settlement discussions conducted in order to avoid or resolve litigation. (A.R.S. §38-431.03A(4))
The City of Mesa is committed to making its public meetings accessible to persons with disabilities.  For special accommodations, please contact the City Manager's Office at (480) 644-3333 or AzRelay 7-1-1 at least 48 hours in advance of the meeting.  Si necesita asistencia o traducción en español, favor de llamar al menos 48 horas antes de la reunión al 480-644-2767

http://mesa11.com/vod/?show=1407