Skip to main content

The Myth of "Making War More Surgical"

Few thinkers are better equipped to answer these questions than Samuel Moyn, a professor of law and history at Yale University and a non-resident fellow at the Quincy Institute, which publishes RS. 
Moyn has long grappled with the relationship between war and morality, most notably in his 2021 book ā€œHumane: How the United States Abandoned Peace and Reinvented War.ā€

Israel's currently in a phase that combines lots and lots of violence with claims to still be following international law. It has had phases of its struggle against Hamas that involved just bombing or its own use of special forces that were about conducting the struggle but making it as antiseptic as possible. It's just that Israel can't conduct that kind of campaign while promising to remove Hamas from power altogether.

Mapping it: Striking US isolation in UN vote
QIOSK

Mapping it: 

Striking US isolation in UN vote


A vast, continuous zone of clear support for a ceasefire is revealed

___________________________________________________________________________________

War is the only proper school for surgeons' | Stars and Stripes


Israeli airstrikes surge in Gaza, destroying homes and killing dozens at a  time | WFXRtv
Historian says there is 'no end in sight' for Israel-Gaza war | Here & Now
We've talked to Israel about making Gaza war more 'surgical', US says
We've talked to Israel about making Gaza war more 'surgical', US says - BBC  News
line
The health ministry in Gaza, which is run by Hamas, says more than 19,400 people have been killed and 52,000 injured in the enclave since the start of the war.
Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin said US support for Israel was "ironclad"
No views Dec 18, 2023


  • Mr. Austin said that he had held discussions with Israeli officials, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, about how to reduce civilian casualties and collateral damage as the operation continues.
  • His remarks align with the US government's recent approach to the war, with officials urging Israel to "put a premium on human life" and give clearer instructions to allow people to avoid the conflict.
  • Senior US officials have also displayed increasing discontent at Israel's military response.

Last week, Mr Biden said Israel was starting to lose global support over what he called its "indiscriminate bombing" of Gaza.

  • But he reiterated that Israel could rely on US support and stressed that he supported its right to defend itself.
  • Concern has mounted over the rising civilian cost of Israeli military operations in the Hamas-run territory, which began after Hamas attacks on Israel on 7 October left around 1,200 Israelis dead.

A Human Rights Watch report released on Monday accused Israel of "using starvation of civilians as a method of warfare in the Gaza Strip, which is a war crime".

US Defence Secretary Lloyd Austin has said he urged Israel to protect civilians in Gaza and make the war there more "surgical".

Mr Austin, who spoke after a meeting with his Israeli counterpart in Tel Aviv, reiterated US support for the offensive against Hamas.

He said Washington would provide more arms, vehicles and munitions to Israel.

US officials have been steadfast in their support of Israel since the 7 October attacks by Hamas.

But President Joe Biden has been under growing pressure, including from within his own Democratic Party, to rein in their military campaign.

Speaking on Monday, Mr Austin said the US would not "dictate timelines or terms" of the war to its ally.

"Our support to Israel's right to defend itself is ironclad... and that's not going to change," he said. "It's critical... that Hamas not be able to threaten Israel from Gaza or even threaten Gaza anymore."

Mr Austin then said he had discussed the objectives of the military campaign and "how to reduce harm to civilians in the battlespace" with his Israeli counterpart Yoav Gallant

"We also have some great thoughts about how to transition from high intensity operations to a lower intensity and more surgical operations," he said.

Mr Gallant, meanwhile, said Israeli forces would "continue to operate in Gaza with different levels of intensity". While Mr Austin has been advising Israel to temper and target its operations since its military campaign began, he has become more outspoken as civilian deaths have increased. He earlier warned that Israel risked replacing a tactical victory with a strategic defeat.

2:35
NOW PLAYING


New

_



_______________________________________________

Israel will 'crush and destroy' Hamas, Netanyahu says - Chicago Sun-Times
Israel-Hamas War Live Updates: Gaza Invasion Continues

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

World Defense News

Flash News: Ukraine Intercepts Russian Kh-59 Cruise Missile Using US VAMPIRE Air Defense System Mounted on Boat. Ukrainian forces have made a major breakthrough in their air defense strategy, successfully intercepting and destroying a Russian Kh-59 cruise missile over the Black Sea with the newly deployed U.S. L3Harris VAMPIRE Surface-to-Air Missile (SAM) system mounted on a high-speed boat.  This marks the first operational use of the VAMPIRE SAM system to intercept a cruise missile, representing a significant leap forward in Ukraine's capability to counter advanced airborne threats.  The achievement was reported on January 25, 2025, via the X account of Clash Report.  Read News Russia - Ukraine War at this link ... Ukrainian forces fire with the US-supplied VAMPIRE SAM system from a high-speed boat, successfully intercepting a Russian Kh-59 cruise missile over the Black Sea in response to an airstrike threat. Screenshot from the video published on the Clash Report X acc...

Trump Inauguration Acts Have Been Announced!

The committee planning Trump’s inaugural ceremonies released a schedule Monday of four days of events centered around the Jan. 20th swearing-in ceremony, which Biden is planning to attend. ā€œPresident Trump is dedicated to uniting the country through the strength, security, and opportunity of his America First agenda,ā€ Steve Witkoff and Kelly Loeffler, the co-chairs of the inaugural committee, said in a statement. . . The Republican's Inauguration Day plans include tea at the White House, the swearing-in ceremony at the Capitol, a congressional luncheon, a parade on Pennsylvania Avenue and a trio of balls. Village People and Carrie Underwood to perform at Trump's inauguration events. . . Other inauguration ceremony performers will include two of the president-elect’s musical favorites, country singer Lee Greenwood and opera singer Christopher Macchio. Euronews.com 49 minutes ago Search inside image Village People and Carrie Underwood to perform at Trump's inauguration events...

Zelenskyy ā€˜a beggar and blackmailer’ – EU state’s PM

11 Jan, 2025 19:21 Home World News The Ukrainian leader needs to stop asking other people for money, Slovakia’s Robert Fico has said Vladimir Zelensky looks on during a joint press conference with European Council President Antonio Costa in Kiev, Ukraine, December 1, 2024  Ā©   Getty Images / Nikoletta Stoyanova ISNA News Agency 6 days ago Search inside image Slovakia's PM: Zelensky a beggar and blackmailer - ISNA Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico has lashed out at Vladimir Zelensky, declaring that the Ukrainian leader’s  ā€œbegging and blackmailingā€  needs  ā€œto stop.ā€  Relations between Bratislava and Kiev soured when Ukraine cut off the flow of Russian gas earlier this month. ā€œI’m not here to hold hands with Zelensky, and I’ll admit, I’m sick of him sometimes,ā€  Fico said at a meeting of the Slovak parliament’s foreign affairs committee on Friday. ā€œHe roams Europe begging and blackmailing, asking others for money,ā€  Fico continued, adding:...